Advertisement

Big Blue legend just said what every Giants fan believes about Eli Manning

Antrel Rolle says Eli Manning deserves his flowers and a spot in Canton
Jason Kandel
Jason Kandel

GMEN HQ

Eli Manning after being named MVP after Super Bowl XLVI in Indianapolis, February 5, 2012. Super Bowl Xlvi New York Giants Vs New England In The First Half / Chris Pedota/NorthJersey.com / USA TODAY NETWORK

The Antrel Rolle media tour continues. The three-time Pro Bowler’s interview with Gambling Industry News reporter Kyle Odegard has turned heads this week for his opinions on Joe Schoen’s decision making and reunion potential for both Odell Beckham Jr and Jason Pierre-Paul in the Big Apple. 

But perhaps his strongest statement came when discussing his former quarterback. Eli Manning has long been at the center of questions regarding his Hall-of-Fame candidacy, but the franchise icon would be on Rolle’s ballot.

“Do I think he will get in? Yes, I do. And I think he deserves to get in,” Rolle said. “And it’s not just because of the name, or because he played in New York. You’re talking about someone who had a very good NFL career, postseason we know what he did.”

Rolle points to playoff résumé in making Manning’s Canton case

Manning, a four-time Pro Bowler, led the Giants to the playoffs six times during his 16-year NFL career, which doesn’t look impressive on paper, but we all know how it ends. The former No. 1 pick led the G-Men to victories in Super Bowl XLII and XLVI, being named Super Bowl MVP in both games.

What’s even crazier is that he was the first quarterback to ever beat Tom Brady in the Super Bowl. Brady is considered to be the greatest player in NFL history, so Rolle doesn’t see that 2011 Super Bowl run as a fluke- it’s legacy-defining.

Yet Manning was still snubbed from the hall in his first year on the ballot.

“Two-time Super Bowl winning quarterback, and the guy (Tom Brady) who he beat in both Super Bowls,” Rolle told Odegard. “That stuff speaks for itself, and it doesn’t happen by accident.” 

Manning has thrown for 18 touchdowns to just nine interceptions in January while completing nearly 61% of his passes. Not half bad.

But that 87.5 playoff passer rating is the one that should stand out regarding the signal-caller’s clutch gene.

“Eli, to me, is clutch. He gets my vote 200% of the time. And this is not me being biased. He is the real deal at quarterback, and I’m hoping he gets his flowers. I know he will. He deserves it.”

Manning's Hall of Fame candidacy remains one of the hottest debates in recent memory. But if former teammates like Rolle have anything to say about it, his ticket to Canton may be inevitable.

For more Giants news and analysis:

Jason Kandel

Jason Kandel

Jason Kandel is a sports junkie with a lifelong passion for storytelling, stats, and strong opinions. He’s been writing for FanSided since early 2025, contributing to Blogging Dirty, GMenHQ, and The Jet Press. Jason graduated from Michigan State University (Go Green!) in May 2025 with a degree in Journalism and a minor in Sports Journalism. He has worked across nearly every form of media, writing for Spartan Sports Report and Impact 89FM, hosting podcasts, and even stepping in front of the camera for Big Ten Student U. Born and raised on Long Island and proud to be a triplet, he brings energy, passion and insight to everything he covers. Ask him about movies, fantasy football, or where to find the best pizza in New York.