The Blame Game: Kevin Gilbride Edition

The Niners and there sparkling 7-1 record took on the Giants and their surprising 6-2 record in a hard fought, nail biting thriller that ended in a heartbreaking Giants loss.

The game, although sloppy, was extremely entertaining in both the defense and offense side of the ball. Eli Manning had a pair of picks, but also had some spectacular throws that proved his elite status thus more. Alex Smith, the former 1st overall pick, did his best to shush the critics on his way to his 8th win of the season.

After the 27-20 loss many names started to get thrown around as to who was at fault. Manningham could have had a spectacular grab in the end zone had he laid out more. Manning had a costly interception on the drive before that set up the game winning drive. Diehl was not successful in covering Justin Smith that led to the turnover on downs, and the game ending.

These 3 man do take a share of blame for the loss, but the man that should be looked at more than anyone is Kevin Gilbride. His lack of creativity on the offensive side of the ball, and his need to run on almost every 2nd down is a great cause of concern. If a draw play was an actual person, I am pretty sure Kevin Gilbride would be married to it.

On the last drive of the game, Manningmanaged to convert 2 out of 3 desperation 4th down conversions. Pretty impressive if you ask me.

Just say No to Gilbride

While in striking distance of the redzone and what seemed to be another Eli Manning 4th quarter comeback, Gilbride did the opposite of his gameplan — He called a passing play on 2nd down. The ball went through Manningham’s hands, and Gilbrides attempt to look like a hero failed. The Giants were only 2 yards away from securing a 1st down, so wouldnt that be the perfect time to run it? Gilbride defies logic, goes for it, and fails. Then to make matters worse he runs it up the gut with DJ Ware instead of Brandon Jacobs on 3rd down and he comes up with no gain.

Incomplete pass, Turnover on Downs, Game over.

Now do not get me wrong, the whole team is at fault for the loss. A loss is the culmination of things not going right. But if you were watching the game or any game for that matter  involving the Giants, then you would see that Gilbride needs to be canned. Plain and simple.

 I don’t blame Buddy Ryan for punching him on the sideline in the Houston Oilers days. Lord knows I would.

For more news, updates, and analysis follow me on Twitter:

Next Giants Game View full schedule »
Monday, Sep 88 Sep7:10at Detroit LionsBuy Tickets
Dick's Sporting Goods presents "Hell Week":

Tags: DJ Ware Eli Manning Giants, New York Giants, Popular, Featured, Justin Tuck Kevin Gilbride Manningham Niners

  • LyleM.Weiser

    Whoever wrote this article should be hired as the next offensive coordinator of the Giants. Dude, I hold you in very high esteem. I.e., agree with you wholeheartedly. Matter of fact, I left a similar post (as yours) on another blog.
    Buddy didn’t punch Gilbride hard enough!!!!!

  • LyleM.Weiser

    Sorry, E. Roberts, you rock, my friend!

  • ERobertsNY

    I appreciate it Lyle. The man (Gilbride) simply does not know what to call in crucial situations. He is literally a drive killer. Sure, he can get Eli to throw for over 300 yds, and a few TD’s, but a loss on a boneheaded draw play or screen pass erases all of that. Any diehard Giants fan or NFL fan for that matter can see how painstakingly obvious it is that he needs to go or change his offensive philosophy for the rest of the season.

  • LyleM.Weiser

    To ERobertsNY

    Totally, totally agree!!!!! What really bothers me about Gilbride is his rigidity. He continues to go back to the well again and again on plays that have failed to work in the past. Moreover, the offense is so predictable. Accordingly, 2009′sThanksgiving eve game (vs. Denver), I amazed my son-in-law (who is an occasional football fan) by calling the first 12 offensive plays correctly as to who was going to receive the ball and where it was going; he thought that I was some kind of genius. I told him that if I can guess the plays, what do you think about the opponent defensive coordinators’ acumen (who review countless hours of film to predict Giants’ offensive patterns)?

    Its truly sad and Gilbride needs to go; I have a feeling that we are not making the playoffs this year. John Mara better seriously consider some significant changes if we continue to have the November/December swoon of the previous Coughlin years.