A Steve Smith Return? What do you think?


Steve Smith of the Philadelphia Eagles is a free agent, and there has been great discussion and speculation that the  Giants should be interested in bringing him back.  Smith was a sensational rookie in 2007, and made some big plays in the Super Bowl, both positive and negative.  In the ensuing years he became a fan favorite and a very reliable receiver.  After injuring his knee, the Giants doctors felt he would be better off starting the season on the PUP list, and Steve decided he would sign with the Eagles for a few dollars more and risk his career.  Smith finished the season playing in 9 games for the Eagles, with 11 catches for 124 yards, and ending up on injured reserve by week 16.

Is Smith healthy? Would he come back to New York? Is this the logical choice to put Victor Cruz outside with Smith reclaiming the slot role?  Smith said some things on the way out the door that were unnecessary, would the fans welcome him back?