New York Giants: Grades for all six draft picks

Saquon Barkley – Grade: A-

Barkley was the best talent in this year’s draft class. He also plays a position that is inherently less valuable than other positions, such as quarterback, defensive end, offensive tackle, and cornerback.

For that reason, the Giants get an A- grade for taking Barkley No. 2 overall. It’s not a knock on the Penn State prospect. He’s an undeniable talent that will make an immediate impact for the Giants and will help the franchise for years to come.

But the chance to select a future franchise quarterback with a top five selection doesn’t come along often, unless you’re the Cleveland Browns. The last time Big Blue had a top five pick they acquired Eli Manning through a trade with the San Diego Chargers.

The Giants clearly didn’t feel the same way about any of these quarterbacks as they did Manning in 2004. And in that instance, Gettleman’s explanation makes plenty of sense, via New York’s website.

"“If you have to try to make yourself fall in love with a player, it is wrong. You will never be happy with the pick. You have to go through the process. As Theo Epstein said, you don’t cheat the process. You get all the information and give everyone their say at the right time. At the end of the day, you shouldn’t have to talk yourself into a guy. If you talk yourself into a guy, you are making a mistake”"

The Giants clearly didn’t have to talk themselves into Barkley. He’s an instant impact playmaker that will help elevate New York’s entire offense. He will also help Big Blue’s defense by controlling the clock, something the Giants have not been able to do for years.