6 potential starting QBs Giants should target to replace Tommy DeVito in 2025

The New York Giants' 2024 campaign has been a trainwreck. After their Thanksgiving loss to the Dallas Cowboys, the Giants are sitting at 2-10, dead last in the NFL, and mathematically eliminated from playoff contention.

Neither Tommy DeVito nor Drew Lock are the long-term answer at quarterback. The Giants, likely holding a top-two pick in the 2025 NFL Draft (currently have the first-overall pick), are perfectly positioned to make a massive upgrade at quarterback.

Whether they go young through the draft or take a swing on a veteran, here are six potential starting quarterbacks the Giants should target:

Six potential starting QBs the Giants could target in 2025

Aaron Rogers

The New York Giants are in dire need of stability at the quarterback position. With Daniel Jones released and backups like Tommy DeVito and Drew Lock failing to inspire confidence, the offense is floundering.

Enter Aaron Rodgers. Despite a tumultuous stint with the Jets, Rodgers remains a future Hall of Famer with the leadership and experience the Giants sorely lack. His ability to elevate an offense could be the catalyst for a franchise turnaround. Moreover, Rodgers' presence would mentor younger players and potentially attract other free agents, bolstering the team's overall competitiveness.

While age and injury history are considerations, the immediate upgrade Rodgers offers might be worth the gamble for a team desperate to reclaim any relevance.

Cam Ward

The New York Giants need a fresh start at quarterback, and Cam Ward from the University of Miami could be the perfect fit. At 6'2", 223 pounds, Ward has the arm talent, mobility, and playmaking ability to elevate any offense. His rapid rise from under-the-radar recruit to a top 2025 draft prospect shows his adaptability and high ceiling.

Ward’s ability to shine against elite competition and lead teams to success makes him an intriguing option for a rebuilding Giants franchise. His dual-threat skills and leadership could inject energy into the offense and give New York the long-term solution it desperately needs. While transitioning to the NFL is never easy, Ward’s potential as a dynamic franchise quarterback is hard to ignore.

Justin Fields

The New York Giants are in dire need of a franchise quarterback, and Justin Fields could be the solution. After a stint with the Pittsburgh Steelers, where he completed 65.8% of his passes for 1,106 yards, five touchdowns, and only one interception in six games, Fields has demonstrated significant growth.

His dual-threat capability adds a dynamic element to the offense, something the Giants have been lacking. With Fields set to become a free agent in 2025, the Giants have a prime opportunity to secure a young, talented quarterback who can lead the team into a new era. His experience and skill set align well with the team's needs, making him a compelling option to revitalize the Giants' offense.

Malik Willis

The New York Giants are in desperate need of a dynamic quarterback, and trading for Green Bay Packers' backup Malik Willis could be a strategic move. Since being acquired by the Packers, Willis has shown promise in limited action, completing 29 of 39 passes for 380 yards and three touchdowns over three games, boasting a passer rating of 130.3.

His dual-threat capability adds a new dimension to the offense, potentially revitalizing a unit that has struggled with consistency. At 25, Willis offers both youth and upside, aligning with the Giants' long-term rebuilding plans. While he may not be a proven star, his potential and playmaking ability make him an interesting option to lead the team's offensive resurgence.

Sam Darnold

Big Blue needs a reliable quarterback, and Sam Darnold, set to become a free agent after a standout season with the Minnesota Vikings, could be the answer. In 11 games this season, Darnold has achieved a career-high passer rating of 101.7, throwing for 2,717 yards, 21 touchdowns, and 10 interceptions.

Darnold's resurgence in Minnesota, leading the team to a 9-2 record, demonstrates his capability to guide a franchise under the right conditions. While the Vikings may consider retaining him, their investment in first-round pick J.J. McCarthy suggests Darnold could explore other opportunities.

His 67.6% completion rate reflects significant growth in accuracy and decision-making. At 27, he offers a blend of experience and youth, aligning well with the Giants' rebuilding timeline. His familiarity with the New York market, from his tenure with the Jets, adds to his appeal. For the Giants, securing Darnold could provide the stability and leadership needed to revitalize the offense and steer the team back to competitiveness.

Shedeur Sanders

The New York Giants are in dire need of a franchise quarterback, and Shedeur Sanders from Colorado could be the ideal solution. Standing at 6'2" and weighing 215 pounds, Sanders has showcased exceptional poise and precision, completing 74.2% of his passes for 3,926 yards and 35 touchdowns over 12 games this season.

Sanders' leadership qualities and football IQ make him a compelling prospect for the Giants, who are seeking stability and playmaking ability at the quarterback position.

Drafting Sanders could provide the Giants with a dynamic and confident leader capable of revitalizing the offense and steering the team toward future success. His ability to read defenses and deliver accurate throws under pressure has been instrumental in Colorado's impressive 9-3 record.

More New York Giants news and analysis