Skip to main content

Arvell Reese’s Giants breakout has put Defensive Rookie of the Year within reach

The odds favor a heated race between two high-profile New York rookies.
ByJake Elman
New York Giants linebacker Arvell Reese
New York Giants linebacker Arvell Reese | USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect

Social media users and WFAN callers need not feel alone in calling New York Giants linebacker Arvell Reese the NFL’s best defensive rookie.

Reese has stuffed the stat sheet through nine games, racking up 81 tackles, eight tackles for loss, 4.5 sacks, and an interception for the first-place Giants. He’s also recorded four pass breakups, a forced fumble, and a fumble recovery en route to solidifying his place among the league’s top young defenders.

Last Sunday’s dominant performance against Philadelphia certainly helped introduce him to those whose attention was focused more on J.J. McCarthy or Malik Nabers. The No. 5 pick earned NFC Defensive Player of the Week honors after tallying 12 tackles, three sacks, and a forced fumble in the Giants’ 19–11 victory over the rival Eagles.

Even in a loss to the Washington Commanders, Reese was all over the field and nabbed his eighth tackle for loss of the season.

Is Giants LB Arvell Reese the favorite to win Defensive Rookie of the Year?

As of Nov. 16, here are the latest Defensive Rookie of the Year odds on FanDuel Sportsbook:

Player

Odds

Arvell Reese, LB, New York Giants

-150

David Bailey, EDGE, New York Jets

+390

Sonny Styles, S, Washington Commanders

+1000

Jacob Rodriguez, LB, Miami Dolphins

+2700

Caleb Downs, S, Dallas Cowboys

+2700

Barring injuries, all signs point to this fittingly being a two-horse race between Reese and Bailey. Let’s not forget that Reese, an All-American at Ohio State, was widely expected to go No. 2 to the Jets throughout the pre-draft process.

Reese’s current pace would produce roughly 153 tackles and 8.5 sacks over 17 games, and some voters may cite team success for potentially choosing him over Bailey. The 2-8 Jets have dropped five straight, and questions continue to mount about embattled coach Aaron Glenn’s job security.  

That said, Myles Garrett won Defensive Player of the Year last season, and Cleveland finished 5-12. Trying to understand why voters do what they do in a given year is a fool’s errand — and to be clear, we’re not saying that Garrett, who earned all 50 first-place votes, didn’t deserve to beat Houston’s Will Anderson. We’ve simply seen enough strange ballots over the years, whether it’s awards or the Hall of Fame.

Would Styles overtake Reese if Washington somehow finishes atop the NFC East? We’re skeptical that’d be the case, largely because Styles lacks the counting stats outside of 80 tackles; he has one interception, a sack, and a forced fumble, and he’s been fine … but fine isn’t always enough. 

Lawrence Taylor remains the only Giants player to win the AP Defensive Rookie of the Year award, doing so during his iconic 1981 season. There’s no reason not to think Reese won’t become the club’s second member by this time in February.

Add us as a preferred source on Google