Kayvon Thibodeaux has gone from top-five pick to budding cornerstone to inconsistent pass rusher to oft-injured question mark to glorified depth piece to trade bait, and now, somehow, to the New York Giants’ last hope of saving a 2026 season that’s falling apart spectacularly by Week 3.
During Sunday’s 12-7 Week 3 win over the Tennessee Titans, the Giants believe to have lost star pass rusher Brian Burns to a torn ACL, prematurely ending his season.
Burns’ injury comes just one week after New York lost its starting quarterback for the year with a season-ending knee injury. Things aren’t exactly going according to plan in the early stages of 2026, but the G-Men sit at 2-1 with a chance to shock the world down two stars.
What Big Blue does at quarterback remains to be seen, but the Brian Burns contingency plan starts and ends with Thibodeaux stepping up and becoming the pass rusher the Giants have held off trading away for the past couple of years.
And now more than ever, barring a complete collapse over the next few weeks, entertaining any trade talks for the 25-year-old seems foolish and incredibly unlikely.
Giants suddenly can’t afford to entertain a Kayvon Thibodeaux trade
The pass rush was once viewed as a major strength, and now it’s one of New York’s biggest weaknesses. Even with Burns for most of the first three games, the G-Men have managed just one sack, with only the Miami Dolphins (zero) recording fewer.
That lone sack belongs to Abdul Carter, which means both Carter and Thibs have some serious stepping up to do.
Earlier in the offseason, general manager Joe Schoen made his stance on trading KT pretty clear by putting Thibs’ asking price at a second-round pick. That’s a steep price to pay for a guy who hasn’t played a full season since 2023 and has 23.5 sacks in four-plus years in the league. If you remove what now looks like an outlier of a 2023 season, when he had 11.5 sacks, his numbers look even worse.
That’s 12 sacks over 39 games. He had just 2.5 last year and has yet to get to the QB this year. Even still, they can’t give up on him just yet.
And if Schoen couldn’t get his second-round price when Thibodeaux’s value was higher, selling low now when the Giants need him more than ever would make even less sense.
He’s in the final year of his rookie deal and should look to get paid either by the Giants or someone else this offseason. Someone might want to remind him of that, seeing as this Casper disappearing act is only hurting his wallet.
Burns’ injury also gives the Giants 14 games to figure out exactly what they have in Thibodeaux. He’ll be back in a full-time role with every opportunity to prove he’s worth another contract, whether that ultimately comes from New York or somewhere else.
The only reason Schoen should even consider moving him before the November 10 trade deadline is if the season goes kaput -- which it very well could -- beforehand. They have five more games between now and then to figure it out.
Add us as a preferred source on Google