Skip to main content

Dexter Lawrence fueling Bengals' Super Bowl push is a twofold blow for the Giants

Cincy’s title aspirations are making Big Blue look worse.
ByLior Lampert
NFL: NOV 01 Titans vs Bengals
NFL: NOV 01 Titans vs Bengals | Icon Sportswire/GettyImages

Revisionist history can be a strange beast, especially when combined with hindsight. Cincinnati Bengals star defensive tackle Dexter Lawrence II, formerly of the New York Giants, is a prime example.

As the story goes, Lawrence requested a trade from the Giants this past offseason after contract extension talks broke down. The two sides reached the point of no return, so the Bengals swooped in and acquired him for the tenth pick in the 2026 NFL Draft. New York turned its new premium asset into a promising young offensive lineman in Francis Mauigoa, while Cincinnati landed a transformative change force; win-win, right?

Well, not exactly.

In his first campaign with the club, Lawrence has been vital to the Bengals' success. They're 7-2 and firmly in the race for the AFC's No. 1 seed, punctuated by their 38-18 Sunday Night Football statement win over the Pittsburgh Steelers. It doesn't help that Mauigoa has struggled a bit as a rookie.

Bengals’ Super Bowl push is exposing a Dexter Lawrence-sized Giants mistake

Cincy looked like a powerhouse in their blowout of Pittsburgh. Superstar quarterback Joe Burrow, the clear MVP favorite so far this year, and Co. did whatever they wanted on offense, but that's nothing new. It's their much-improved defense, headlined by Lawrence, that's vaulting them to elite status.

Despite posting just one tackle (which went for a loss), Lawrence was everywhere against the Steelers. He blew up runs and screens, ate double teams, set teammates up with advantageous matchups — the list goes on. There was also a takedown of Pittsburgh signal-caller Aaron Rodgers that won't show up in the box score. It was a vintage "Sexy Dexy" performance.

Through nine games this season, Lawrence has been downright sensational. He's recorded the fourth-most defensive stops (22), is fourth in hurries (22) and is tied for fourth in total pressures (31) among all interior defenders. The two-time All-Pro is near the top at his position in both pass- and run-block win rates.

Lawrence has almost single-handedly turned the Bengals into a middle-of-the-pack stop unit in expected points added (EPA) per play. That might not sound like much, but it's drastically better than what we've seen from them across the last few years. Look no further than their No. 29 ranking in that category from 2023 through 2025, when they missed the playoffs annually.

Could you imagine Lawrence on Big Blue's current defense? They'd go gangbusters. To rub extra salt in the wound, he's been exactly what they were scouring the league for ahead of the recent trade deadline.

Giants' DT search makes Dexter Lawrence's success with Bengals even worse

New York reportedly actively explored the market for DT help before the Nov. 10 cutoff. They went big-game hunting, too, inquiring about Jeffery Simmons, a true disruptor, before the Tennessee Titans shipped him to the Chicago Bears. Yet, the front office ironically already had the one-man wrecking crew they tried to find, albeit to no avail.

Sometimes, it's funny how things work. The G-Men already had the stud D-lineman they coveted in November on the roster back in April. However, for whatever reason(s), the new regime led by Super Bowl-winning head coach John Harbaugh didn't want to pay Lawrence.

Roughly a handful of months later, the Giants are clearly eager to replicate what they lost in Lawrence. It makes you wonder why the organization didn't meet his demands instead of hoping to replace him.

Note: Advanced metrics courtesy of Fantasy Points' data suite 2.0 and Pro Football Focus' premium stats. Subscription required for both.

Add us as a preferred source on Google