Skip to main content

John Harbaugh's belief in Dominic Zvada is becoming impossible to defend

How many misses is it going to take?
ByMichael Haney
New York Giants kicker Dominic Zvada
New York Giants kicker Dominic Zvada | USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect

What's the saying? "Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me?" Well, Dominic Zvada is heaping shame on John Harbaugh this season. The rookie kicker has let the New York Giants down time and time again, but his head coach continues to put his trust in him.

Even after a brutal showing from Zvada against the Washington Commanders in Week 10, Harbaugh refuses to give up on the rookie.

Speaking to the media about Zvada after practice on Wednesday, Harbaugh said, "He had a great day today; he was dead on. He hit the middle pole, the camera pole, numerous times, kicking field goals, and from the right hash, the amazing, scary right hash."

It's encouraging to hear that Zvada has been hitting his kicks in practice, especially from the right hash that has given him so much trouble this year, but we need to see some improvement in games before we reach Harbaugh's level of confidence in the kicker.

John Harbaugh refuses to give up on Dominic Zvada, and it's hurting the Giants

When it comes to his trust in Zvada, Harbaugh's words and his actions haven't always aligned. He only says positive things about the kicker, as most good coaches would, but he doesn't seem eager to let him kick field goals when the game hangs in the balance.

In the loss to Washington, New York passed up a 54-yard field goal, instead taking a delay-of-game penalty before punting. That range is almost automatic for the best kickers in the league, but Harbaugh seems hesitant to trot Zvada out there in those situations.

It's hard to blame the veteran head coach. Zvada ranks 25th in field goal accuracy among qualifying kickers this season and has shanked kicks in key moments. If the G-Men had a kicker they could trust, they might be running away with the NFC East title right now.

The Giants are leaving points on the field, both through Zvada's misses and through Harbaugh's hesitation to put him out there. At this point, it's hard to say how many misses it will take for Harbs to finally seek out a replacement.

Giants' Dominic Zvada will have to be better than ever against the Jaguars in Week 11

New York needs a kicker it can trust more than ever in a Week 11 bout with the Jacksonville Jaguars. Jacksonville is gearing up for a Super Bowl run after making multiple moves at the trade deadline, and it already had one of the league's best defenses.

According to SumerSports, the Jaguars' defense ranks third in EPA per play and fourth in success rate. They're allowing just 16 points per game, which ranks second in the league. With Jordan Davis and Jessie Bates III joining the defensive roster, Jacksonville will be even more difficult to score against.

Big Blue's offense is going to have to fight for every yard on Sunday. If Zvada can't reward positive drives with points, the Giants will have little chance of pulling off an upset. He's capable of making long field goals - he has hit six from beyond 50 yards this year - but he needs to be consistent enough to trust.

Add us as a preferred source on Google