Skip to main content

John Harbaugh is playing it too safe with Giants' playoff hopes at stake

You play to win the game, John.
ByLogan VanDine
New York Giants - head coach John Harbaugh
New York Giants - head coach John Harbaugh | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

New York Giants fans are still feeling the pain after the team's demoralizing loss to the Washington Commanders Thursday night.

The Giants wasted a golden opportunity to further stretch their lead in the NFC East and perhaps put the division away for good. New York, instead, now has to gear up for what is expected to be a grueling last seven games of the year and hope it can still make the playoffs as NFC East champs.

But if the G-Men want to win their first NFC East title since 2011-2012, seemingly against all odds, head coach John Harbaugh needs to change his play-calling style fast.

John Harbaugh must show more agressiveness for these final seven games of the season

In an article for CBS Sports, Zachary Pereles called out Harbaugh's lack of aggressive play-calling that resulted in the Giants' crushing loss.

"There are two conservative choices Harbaugh made late in the fourth quarter that stand out. The first was fourth-and-1 at the Giants' own 11-yard line with 3:26 left," Pereles wrote.

"After a Jayden Daniels interception, the Giants again played it safe with three straight runs, including a designed J.J. McCarthy run on third and 3. Sonny Styles sniffed it out for a 2-yard loss; the Commanders had been all over McCarthy's designed runs. Models were split on the fourth-and-5 decision; the Giants punted again, and to make matters worse, Jordan Stout shanked the punt 12 yards. Daniels led the game-winning touchdown drive, and Washington now has life."

Sorry, Giants fans, but we have to relive these moments that Pereles is alluding to against the Commanders on Thursday. The first moment came after Jevón Holland intercepted Jayden Daniels in the end zone late in the fourth quarter, when the Commanders were in position to retake the lead.

Big Blue was unable to pick up a first down on the ensuing drive as the now-infamous Jameis Winston "Who let dogs out?" cadence clearly did not fool the Commanders' defense on fourth-and-1, resulting in the Giants taking a delay-of-game penalty and punting from their own 11-yard line. Going for it that deep in their own territory would've been a gamble, but punting gave Washington another chance to win the game.

The Giants had another opportunity to bury Washington after Daniels was picked off on the second straight drive by Ar'Darius Washington with less than two and a half minutes to go in regulation.

But of course, New York couldn't milk the clock and ice the game. Right out of the two-minute warning on third-and-3, instead of handing the ball off to Cam Skattebo, who was having a great game on the ground, the team opted to run a designed QB run with J.J. McCarthy that went backward.

Matt Nagy calls the offensive plays, but Harbaugh ultimately oversees the team's late-game approach. After two interceptions, the G-Men had two chances to put Washington away and failed to do so.

The rest of that game was history, which we don't need to relive again.

Despite Harbaugh bringing a superb resume and keeping the Giants atop the division despite the injuries they have faced, this was one of the top concerns many had about the Super Bowl-winning head coach. His inability to finish games.

In his 18 seasons as an NFL head coach, Harbaugh has blown 47 fourth-quarter leads, which is reportedly the most in the league since 2008. His 18-plus-year tenure is worth acknowledging when looking at that number, but it's still a concern after what happened Thursday night.

If the Giants want to maintain their first-place lead in the NFC East, Harbaugh needs to coach much more aggressively and avoid repeating what happened Thursday night against the division foe.

Add us as a preferred source on Google