The New York Giants are staring down one of their most pivotal offseasons in years. After a dismal 3-14 campaign, the franchise is in full reset mode, likely with a rookie quarterback leading the way in 2025. As the Giants evaluate how to surround their potential new signal-caller with the right talent, one surprising name could be on the trade block: Jalin Hyatt.
Now, before you clutch your Malik Nabers jersey and roll your eyes at your screen, hear us out. Hyatt isn’t a bad player. In fact, his talent is undeniable. The problem? He’s stuck in an offense that can’t figure out how to use him, and his non-committal comments about his future with the team suggest he might feel the same way.
When asked about his role going forward, Hyatt told reporters, “We got some talks we gotta have, but we’ll see.” Normally upbeat and engaged, Hyatt seemed much different in the locker room after the season finale—a clear indication that frustration is simmering beneath the surface.
Jalin Hyatt is asked about his future with the Giants:
— Giants Videos (@SNYGiants) January 6, 2025
"We'll see" pic.twitter.com/oawn8n25iq
If Hyatt isn’t sold on his role in New York, and the Giants aren’t fully committed to him, trading him now while he still has value might be the savviest play for both sides.
The Giants should trade WR Jalin Hyatt in the offseason
Let’s be honest: Hyatt hasn’t been a focal point for the Giants’ offense. Despite appearing in 16 games this past season, he managed just eight catches for 62 yards. Part of that is on the team—New York’s offense was a mess—but part of it is the reality of the Giants’ wide receiver depth chart.
Wan'Dale Robinson emerged as a reliable option, Malik Nabers looks like a future star, and Darius Slayton continues to hold down a veteran presence. Hyatt, meanwhile, seemed to fade into the background.
Here’s the thing: Hyatt still has value. Teams looking for a young, speedy deep threat might be willing to take a chance on him. For the Giants, who are likely drafting/acquiring a rookie/young quarterback, flipping Hyatt for draft capital or an established player might be the better play. A young quarterback needs stability, and banking on a developmental receiver while still finding his way might not be the best strategy.
This isn’t to say Hyatt is a bust or that the Giants should dump him out of frustration. But trading him while his potential remains intriguing could be a win-win. He gets a fresh start, and the Giants gain assets to help solidify their rebuild.
In the end, Hyatt’s non-committal stance and lack of production don’t necessarily spell the end of his time in New York, but they make a strong case for exploring trade options. The Giants need clarity as they chart their future, and moving Hyatt could be one step toward that goal. Whether it’s a tough call or not, it might be the right one.