We've gone through a bit of a rollercoaster with Matt Nagy. The New York Giants' decision to hire him as their offensive coordinator was met with a collective groan that could have been heard from Long Island. He won our hearts, though, especially through his ability to unlock J.J. McCarthy with such a limited runway.
Now, we're realizing that we were right to doubt him all along. While the first two games of McCarthy's time as New York's starter were surprisingly watchable, Nagy's offense has quickly become so limited that defenses have no trouble stopping it.
If the OC doesn't change things soon, his one-dimensional scheme could sink Big Blue's playoff hopes.
Matt Nagy isn't doing the Giants any favors with his play calling
Football should be a blank canvas for an offensive play caller. With 11 players to deploy in any way that suits the rulebook, the possibilities should be endless. In the passing game, Nagy has limited himself to just a few basic concepts.
In Thursday's loss to the Washington Commanders, the G-Men ran multiple wide receiver screens. A few of them went to Malik Nabers, who isn't the most elusive receiver with the ball in his hands. The Commanders snuffed those plays out without a hitch. Nabers averaged just 1.75 yards on his four catches fewer than ten yards downfield.
When the unsuccessful screen passes lead to third down and long, Nagy has one go-to call. He calls an intermediate or deep out-breaker to either Nabers or Malachi Fields. To be fair, it's McCarthy's best throw. The young QB has completed the most intermediate out-breakers in the league since Week 6, and that includes New York's bye.
But teams are going to catch on if Nagy doesn't switch it up more often. Maybe he's just trying to limit McCarthy's mental workload, but if he doesn't make a change soon, his offense is going to lose its ability to move the ball.
Matt Nagy has to hand J.J. McCarthy the keys to the Giants' offense
Nagy has to trust McCarthy. Yes, he's a young quarterback with limited experience who arrived in New York about a month ago. He's not set up to succeed. But the Giants have no other choice. Without a consistently dominant running game or an elite defense, they're going to have to lean on McCarthy to take them to the playoffs.
For Nagy, that means opening up the playbook. McCarthy has already shown that he can make just about any throw on the field. His touchdown over the middle of the field to Isaiah Likely against Washington was the best throw any Giants QB has made this season. Why not give him the reins to the offense moving forward?
With each passing week, opposing defenses will have more film of McCarthy to review. It won't be long before the rest of the league knows what's coming if Nagy continues to keep the offense as simple as he has so far.
For the sake of the NFC East title chase, Nagy has to put more on McCarthy's plate.
