It's back to the drawing board for the New York Giants following their disappointing Week 10 loss. They had several chances to beat the Washington Commanders, but alas, a few costly mistakes proved to be the difference.
Despite falling to 5-3-1, there are plenty of notable takeaways, including the efforts (or lack thereof) of several soon-to-be Giants free agents. Some positive, and some ... not so much.
Roughly halfway through 2026, let's check in on a handful of New York players who are set to hit the open market this coming offseason. The impact they've had (or haven't had) on the club's pleasantly surprising success so far, and moving forward, could determine their future.
New York Giants 2027 impending free agent tracker
S Ar'Darius Washington
Washington has quickly gone from rotational piece to full-time contributor over the past month, and for good reason. He's more than earned the right to be the Giants' starting safety opposite ball hawk Jevón Holland, specifically in coverage. It culminated in a primetime showcase performance against the Commanders.
When New York needed Washington most in the fourth quarter on Thursday Night Football, he delivered. The veteran made outstanding back-to-back plays to force a turnover on downs. His interception with roughly two minutes remaining gave them a chance to ice the contest (to no avail).
Since Week 7, when he officially climbed to the top of the depth chart, Washington has been phenomenal when thrown at. He's given up the second-fewest receiving yards (43) among 73 defensive backs who've been targeted at least 10 times during this stretch. His 18.4 passer rating allowed is the second-lowest, trailing only Cleveland Browns Pro Bowl cornerback Denzel Ward.
Spending the past five campaigns with head coach John Harbaugh during their overlap with the Baltimore Ravens got Washington's foot in the door. However, he's looking like a potential keeper, dispatching 2024 second-round pick Tyler Nubin as Holland's running mate.
RB Devin Singletary
At this point, there's not much to say about Singletary. He was a healthy scratch at times earlier this season. A golden fill-in opportunity to stake his claim in New York's running back plans failed spectacularly.
The Giants called on Singletary for just five offensive snaps in their defeat at the hands of the Commanders. He ran two routes and had one three-yard carry. His virtually nonexistent usage notably came while fellow RB Tyrone Tracy Jr. was still out with a hamstring injury.
Singletary, 29, has been relegated to a minimal special teams role. It's become abundantly clear that "Motor's" best days are behind him, and the G-Men seem to be coming to grips with this in real time. He won't be relied on heavily, if at all, as the playoff race heats up, which tells us what we need to know regarding his future.
CB Deonte Banks
Banks will get paid when March rolls around. If not the Giants, someone will reward him for what's been a strong bounce-back year. The talented young cornerback has rediscovered his rookie form and reminded everyone why he was a first-round selection in the 2023 NFL Draft.
No pass-catcher has recorded more than two receptions or 36 receiving yards with Banks as the pre-snap matchup this season. He's 115th and 119th, respectively, out of 134 defensive backs with 20-plus targets in opponent completion percentage (53.8) and expected points added per target. The Maryland product is proving he can go toe-to-toe with the league's best wide receivers and be a legitimate shutdown corner.
Perhaps no one has benefited more from Harbaugh and defensive coordinator Dennard Wilson landing in East Rutherford than Banks. It's another example of the effect good coaching can have.
WR Darnell Mooney
While Mooney has popped up for the occasional deep shot for Big Blue, he hasn't been a trustworthy weapon. More than half of his routes have come from the slot, which typically means higher-volume, lower-depth touches, though stud tight end Isaiah Likely complicates matters.
Likely lines up inside on over 80 percent of his routes and is a focal point of the aerial attack. He and Mooney have both done their damage in similar areas of the field, and the former is far and away the preferred option. Not to mention, the Giants also employ a certified alpha wideout in Malik Nabers, who commands a rather large share of the pie.
Nabers and Likely have accounted for more than half of the team's receiving workload and production combined through nine games.
Third-round rookie Malachi Fields continues to flash big-play upside and has seen a slight bump in opportunities after the bye. Mooney converted two of five looks for eight scoreless yards against Washington, is the fourth fiddle at best and will presumably be replaced in due course.
LB Micah McFadden
Man, in hindsight, McFadden re-signing with New York last offseason was such a fortunate turn of events. He reportedly had "quite a few suitors" before opting to rejoin the squad despite the addition of another, far more established linebacker, Tremaine Edmunds.
Well, Edmunds suffered a season-ending torn chest muscle in mid-October. His absence left a massive void in the middle of the defense; he was an every-down guy and wore the green dot to make play calls. McFadden has assumed those responsibilities, and impressively, the drop-off has been minimal.
McFadden has been everywhere in the Giants' three most recent outings. He's posted 29 tackles (four for loss), three quarterback hits, one sack and a fumble recovery. Turning 27 in January, would anyone be surprised to see him get priced out of the front office's range?
C John Michael Schmitz
The writing's been on the wall for Schmitz, who lost his job in September. He's barely been involved since his demotion to backup center duties behind Bryan Hudson. The latter's emergence makes this a pretty cut-and-dry situation.
A holdover from New York's previous regime, Schmitz hasn't made a great impression on the new staff. He was supposed to be one of the most pro-ready prospects of the 2023 draft class, yet that hasn't materialized. Both sides might be better off cutting their losses and moving on.
Note: Advanced metrics courtesy of Fantasy Points' data suite 2.0 ($).
