Giants player exposes MetLife’s brutal double standard on player safety

The war between natural grass and artificial turf is heating up again—because apparently, football players need to be reminded they’re second-class citizens in their own stadium.

NFL players and the NFLPA have been loud and clear about this: they overwhelmingly prefer grass fields. The data backs them up, and the injuries keep piling up. Yet more than half of the NFL still plays on turf. Why? Simple. It’s cheaper to maintain, and nothing says “we value our athletes” like cutting corners on player safety.

So when New York Giants offensive lineman Jermaine Eluemunor saw MetLife Stadium rolling out a fresh, pristine layer of natural grass for the upcoming FIFA Club World Cup, he had the same reaction any sane football player would. He reposted the PIX11 video with a meme that said what everyone was already thinking: "Seriously? This is what we’re doing?"

They’ll dig up the whole field for a sport that’ll be gone in two weeks, but Giants and Jets players still get to blow out their knees on turf come September?

NFLPA’s turf fight gets more ammunition after MetLife’s World Cup makeover

This isn’t just one frustrated lineman lashing out. Eluemunor’s tweet echoed what players across the league—and their union—have been saying for years. The NFLPA itself chimed in with a quote tweet of the new grass field, adding, “Looks nice… #SaferFields.”

Not subtle at all.

The players have numbers to back up their frustration—and one of the loudest voices is NFLPA president JC Tretter. He’s been relentless in his push for natural grass across all stadiums, pointing to years of injury data and firsthand experience as evidence that turf simply isn’t safe.

Tretter has cited studies from 2012 to 2018 showing a 28% higher rate of non-contact lower extremity injuries on artificial turf, including a 32% spike in knee injuries and a staggering 69% increase in foot and ankle issues.

He’s also zeroed in on slit film turf—one of the most widely used and widely hated surfaces in the league—calling for an outright ban due to its even higher injury correlation. Players have backed up the data with real experience, repeatedly saying turf leaves them sore, stiff, and nursing nagging injuries they don’t get on grass. Tretter himself has admitted to spending more time on the ice machine after turf games than grass ones.

Even with all of this out in the open, the NFL continues to shrug, citing “inconclusive” data and claiming more study is needed. Well... where are the studies they're conducting?

Meanwhile, MetLife Stadium just had truckloads of grass laid down like it was no big deal. It’s hard not to notice how quickly the logistics fall into place when another sport demands safer conditions. FIFA doesn't allow World Cup match events to be played on anything but natural grass. For NFL players, the message is clear: if you want to be protected, go play the other football.

Eluemunor said the quiet part out loud. Now let’s see if anyone listens.

More New York Giants news and analysis