If there's one thing New York Giants fans were hoping to see in Year 1 under John Harbaugh, it was a return to the playoffs. Nobody was asking for a Super Bowl ring or anything unreasonable, but after years of incompetence, the goal was to see a more experienced staff and end a four-year playoff drought.
Fortunately, the NFC East has become the Giants' for the taking, The Cowboys' defense can't stop a nosebleed, the Eagles have been ravaged by injuries, and the Commanders are one of the least consistent teams in the NFL, but the schedule is also due to get a lot tougher these next few weeks.
New York is set to host the Jaguars in Week 11, and they have the 49ers, Seahawks, Browns, and Lions on the docket during the playoff push. Suffice it to say that is no cakewalk. And while they've beaten a lot of weaker opponents, they lack a true statement win against a playoff-level opponent.
ESPN's Seth Walder tiered all 32 teams based off their playoff chances, and he placed the Giants in the "On the fringe of hope and despair" tier alongside the Cowboys, Rams, Browns, Packers, and Panthers, a bunch of other teams that, while talented, are not clear playoff locks at this point in 2026.
The New York Giants' playoff hopes are not as legit as we think
Walder acknowledged that while Big Blue has been a pleasant surprise despite losing Jaxson Dart and Brian Burns to season-ending injuries, it's impressive how they remain afloat at 5-3-1. However, he's unsure how trustworthy this team can actually be across the back half of the season.
"There's a shocking amount of optimism for the Giants during a season in which they lost starting quarterback Jaxson Dart to injury," Walder wrote. "J.J. McCarthy (acquired via trade) has looked better than expected, rookie linebacker Arvell Reese seems like a big hit and somehow the Giants are in first place in the lowly NFC East. But can McCarthy (who has only a 53.9 QBR this season) really be trusted? We'll find out in the back half of the campaign. And after New York's loss to the Commanders on Thursday, the Giants' playoff position is looking shakier than it was entering Week 10."
The burning question we all have about the playoff push is about J.J. McCarthy. In Week 10, he showed that some of the mistakes we saw from him in Minnesota are still in there. When he's playing with confidence, he's been effective. But will he have the same success facing teams that are more talented on both sides of the football and make it their mission to throw him off balance?
The other concern is about the run game, since the ground game has been woefully inefficient.. They can't break off explosive runs, and they lack a true feature back, which will make it hard to go toe-to-toe with teams that can run the football like the Lions, Seahawks, and 49ers. Outside of Malik Nabers and somewhat Isaiah Likely, the offense lacks the star power to keep up with these teams.
The Giants have found ways to win games, albeit in incredibly stressful ways, but that's a product of the coaching job Harbaugh has done. Outside of Thursday's loss to the Commanders, they've played incredibly clean football, and Dennard Wilson's defense has taken major strides in just nine games.
Speaking of defenses, the G-Men haven't faced many near the top of the NFL. The only top-10 unit they faced this season was in Week 2 against the Rams, and while Dart got hurt, they still got locked down. The Seahawks lead the NFL in total defense, while the Jags just made some huge blockbuster deals at the deadline, and the Niners also have units inside the top 10 in total yards allowed per game.
Given that so many aspects of this team are unproven, especially under center, it's hard to believe the playoff hopes are truly legit. The New York Giants at least have something to go off of after the Cowboys' loss on Sunday, but it's hard to buy into the playoff drought ending with this daunting schedule looming.
