Skip to main content

Giants’ WR overhaul could complicate things for Matt Nagy more than expected

Could the Calvin Austin III and Darnell Mooney signings come back to haunt the Giants' offense?
Kansas City Chiefs - offensive coordinator Matt Nagy
Kansas City Chiefs - offensive coordinator Matt Nagy | Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images

The New York Giants are going to look a lot different on offense next year, and a big reason is the changes to their wide receiver room: Wan’Dale Robinson departed in free agency for the Titans, and the G-Men brought in veteran wideouts Calvin Austin III and Darnell Mooney.

There could be more changes coming, as the draft is just a few weeks away. Depending on who the team selects, it could continue to shake things up and give the new-look Giants offense, led by offensive coordinator Matt Nagy, a different look in 2026.

Either way, Jaxson Dart will have more weapons to work with next season, which gives Giants fans a lot to look forward to. The G-Men signed Isaiah Likely in free agency, could draft a player like Jeremiyah Love or Carnell Tate, and are even getting rumors about Odell Beckham Jr. in 2026. For now, Big Blue will bring in Austin and Mooney, but that could raise some concerns for the other weapons on New York’s offense.

Giants may have run themselves into a dead end with their WR signings

Ben Solak of ESPN recently ranked all 32 NFL rosters based on their improvements through free agency, placing the Giants at 26th. This ranking feels a little harsh, as the Giants made moves in free agency and weren’t completely asleep at the wheel.

John Harbaugh and Joe Schoen were active in bringing in players who improved the roster. However, Solak’s analysis of how Austin and Mooney fit in is an interesting point that could raise some concerns.

First off, Solak said he loved what the G-Men did to get off Bobby Okereke’s contract and bring in Tremaine Edmunds. He also said that once the Giants bring in Sonny Styles through the draft, he’ll be more on board with the offseason they are having. What he didn’t like, though, was the redundancy at wide receiver.

Solak says that Austin does help fill some holes left by Robinson, specifically in the slot receiver role, but Mooney, similar to Slayton, is a drop-prone, field-stretching receiver. If you remember, Nagy played a huge role in recruiting Mooney to the Giants and away from the Eagles, as he had a relationship with him from his time as the Bears’ head coach, when he drafted the 28-year-old.

The part that Solak was mainly concerned about with these signings is that Nagy’s offenses with the Chiefs did not have receivers who could block, which caused issues in the run game, and he fears the same could happen with the Giants.

While that’s a good point and definitely a concern, let me remind you that the Chiefs didn’t need run-blocking receivers because Travis Kelce handled that, and they also didn’t have a true RB1, with Isiah Pacheco sidelined for several games.

That is something I’d keep my eye on for the Giants, but Big Blue did sign fullback Pat Ricard, also known as “Pancake Pat,” whose job is essentially to be a run blocker, and Cam Skattebo can practically run through people as well. I also wouldn’t underestimate Theo Johnson’s ability to block, so I think the G-Men will be in good hands in that department.

Loading recommendations... Please wait while we load personalized content recommendations