Which members of the NY Giants are in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

These Giants legends are rightfully honored in Canton.
Indianapolis Colts v New York Giants
Indianapolis Colts v New York Giants / Jim McIsaac/GettyImages
facebooktwitterreddit

Perhaps no team in the NFL is better represented on the Pro Football Hall of Fame's inaugural ballot than the NY Giants. Of the team's 33 former members and executives currently enshrined in Canton, five got in with that very first group.

Names like Tim Mara, Jim Thorpe, and Pete Henry really help illustrate just how important the Giants were for the league when it was first getting started, and how the history of the NFL can't be told without mentioning Big Blue. Here's the whole list of guys:

Which members of the Giants are in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

NAME

POSITION/TITLE

YEAR INDUCTED

Morten Anderson

K

2017

Morris Badgro

E

1981

Roosevelt Brown

OL/T

1975

Harry Carson

LB

2006

Larry Csonka

HB/FB

1987

Ray Flaherty

HC/E

1976

Benny Friedman

RB/QB

2005

Frank Gifford

HB/FB

1977

Joe Guyon

RB/QB

1966

Mel Hein

U/C

1963

Wilbur (Pete) Henry

U/T

1963

Arnie Herber

RB/QB

1966

Robert (Cal) Hubbard

U/T

1963

Sam Huff

LB

1982

Alphonse Leemans

RB/QB

1978

Wellington Mara

Contributor

1977

Tim Mara

Contributor

1963

Don Maynard

WR

1987

Hugh McElhenny

HB/FB

1970

Steve Owen

HC/U

1966

Bill Parcells

HC

2013

Andy Robustelli

DL/DE

1971

Michael Strahan

DL/DE

2014

Ken Strong

RB/QB/HB

1967

Fran Tarkenton

QB

1986

Lawrence Taylor

LB

1999

Jim Thorpe

RB/QB/HB

1963

Y.A. Tittle

QB

1971

Emlen Tunnell

DB/S

1967

Kurt Warner

QB

2017

Arnie Weinmeister

DL/DT

1984

George Young

Contributor

2020

As for the next wave of Giants players who may find their way into the Hall of Fame one day, here are a couple of names to keep an eye on:

Eli Manning

It would make so many people mad. And while Eli Manning was a prolific quarterback in New York for the better part of two decades, his candidacy does kind of come down to "he beat Tom Brady in the Super Bowl twice." And maybe that's fine! No one else could. And sure, the box score stats are plenty impressive: over 57,000 passing yards, 234 starts in 236 games, 366 touchdowns, etc.

However, he also probably was never quite as good as his reputation suggested, which is just a perk of the job when you win multiple rings in New York. His Football Reference Hall of Fame monitor has him coming up short, but again – two rings, longtime New York quarterback, his last name is Manning. There's going to be quite the push to get him in, mark my words.

Odell Beckham Jr.

There was a time where this felt like a lock – through his first three seasons, Odell Beckham Jr. had two All-Pro nods, three Pro Bowls, *35* touchdown catches, and eclipsed 1,300 receiving yards every year. He also had arguably the most recognizable and iconic touchdown catch in the last ... 10? 20 years? He was immediately a star, and looked like a generational wide receiver.

Things haven't gone nearly as well since 2017, though, and even with the occasional flash of greatness, he's kind of been 'Just A Guy' for a half-decade. Injuries have really taken their toll, and even at just 31, it feels like OBJ's on his last couple of seasons in the NFL. He probably wasn't good enough for long enough to be considered seriously, but his special catch vs. Dallas will be shown in Hall of Fame montages for the rest of time.

feed