Since J.J. McCarthy took over the starting role under center in Week 7 against Houston, he's looked every bit of what the New York Giants needed to stay in contention for the NFC East title.
Big Blue is 2-1 and even ended the 13-year losing streak in Philadelphia with No. 18 (9 2.0) at the helm. With how McCarthy has looked, it begs the question: What will the Giants do once Jaxson Dart is healthy?
As encouraging as his play has been so far, the best option for Big Blue might be to trade him away in the offseason.
Giants could trade J.J. McCarthy to the Steelers in the offseason
According to Bleacher Report's Brent Sobleski, McCarthy is going to be a Pittsburgh Steeler this time next year. In his article, Sobleski alludes to McCarthy being able to step in for Aaron Rodgers and allowing the Steelers to avoid a full rebuild.
And honestly, this is a move that would make sense for both teams. The Steelers have the extra draft capital, and the Giants could use more picks to fill in the remaining roster holes.
Unless McCarthy gets the Giants to the NFC Championship, there won't be a QB controversy in the Meadowlands. Once Dart is healthy, the job is his, despite how McCarthy has looked. McCarthy hasn't done enough to take the job, but he has done enough for a team that will be desperate for a QB to potentially overpay in the offseason.
The Giants have all the leverage when it comes to J.J. McCarthy
Fortunately, the Giants' front office holds all the power for McCarthy's future. He's under contract potentially through 2028 if the fifth-year option is picked up. So, if the Giants are unsure of Dart's health or simply want an upgrade over Jameis Winston as the backup QB, they can keep McCarthy in the building.
On the flip side, if he continues to look like a guy whose career was revitalized once he left Minnesota, the Giants can capitalize and flip him for draft capital. Then the Giants could really be playing with house money. They could use extra picks to fill roster holes, or even package those picks to get a key player. The possibilities are truly endless.
If the Giants believe Dart is the guy, which all signs point to the fact that they do, the move would be to flip McCarthy in the offseason to a team like Pittsburgh and sell high. Thankfully, the Giants have leverage to keep him in-house if they want to and don't need to make any rash decisions.
