Skip to main content

Top 20 greatest one-season wonders in New York Giants franchise history

It’s time we start putting more respect on the Giants’ one-season wonders!
ByAdam Bernstein
Sep 15, 2013; East Rutherford, NJ, USA; New York Giants running back David Wilson (22) runs with the ball against the Denver Broncos during a game at MetLife Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Brad Penner-USA TODAY Sports
Sep 15, 2013; East Rutherford, NJ, USA; New York Giants running back David Wilson (22) runs with the ball against the Denver Broncos during a game at MetLife Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Brad Penner-USA TODAY Sports | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The New York Giants are the fourth-oldest franchise in the National Football League. They joined the NFL in 1925, during the league’s sixth season. The 2026-27 season marks the Giants’ 102nd season in the NFL. The team has had plenty of success, winning eight championships, including four in the Super Bowl era.

Several of the NFL’s greatest players in history have suited up for the Giants. With more than 2,000 players appearing in at least one game for the G-Men, it’s hard to keep track of every player. We remember the legends who helped Big Blue win their championships and played with the team for several years, but the one-season wonders don’t often get enough recognition.

One-season wonders aren’t necessarily players who only played one season with the Giants. They are players who had an exceptional year with the Giants and never played at that level again, either in their NFL career or with the team. That said, let’s take a look at the 20 greatest one-season wonders in New York Giants franchise history:

The 20 greatest one-season wonders in New York Giants history

1. RB David Wilson - 2012 season

Starting us off is one of the New York Giants’ biggest ‘what-ifs’: running back and return specialist David Wilson, drafted with the team's 32nd overall pick in the 2012 NFL Draft. In the 2012 season, he totaled 1,925 all-purpose yards, with 1,533 coming on kickoff returns. Against the Saints, he set a team record for all-purpose yards in a single game, totaling 327, including a 97-yard touchdown.

Wilson returned for the 2013 season but played just five games before suffering a season-ending neck injury. After neck surgery, doctors advised him that he should never play football again, and he announced his retirement shortly after. It makes you wonder what else Wilson would’ve accomplished in a Giants uniform if his career hadn't been cut short.

2. WR Steve Smith - 2009 season

Former Giants wide receiver Steve Smith was a key part of Big Blue's 2007 Super Bowl-winning team over the New England Patriots, but his biggest leap came in 2009. In 16 games, Smith caught 107 passes for 1,220 yards and seven touchdowns, earning Pro Bowl honors. Although he went on to play three more seasons in the NFL, including one more in New York, he never again had as many receptions, yards, or touchdowns in a single season.

3. CB Stevie Brown - 2012 season

Stevie Brown joined the Giants' secondary in 2012 after two seasons with the Raiders and Colts. He had yet to record his first NFL interception and had started only one game in his rookie season with Oakland. That changed with his breakout season for Big Blue. Brown replaced an injured Kenny Phillips for the first half of the season, started 11 games, and finished with eight interceptions for 307 return yards, ranking as the fourth-highest single-season total in NFL history.

4. RB Derrick Ward -2008 season

Derrick Ward played eight seasons in the NFL and spent five years with the Giants, but none was quite like his 2008 season, in which he totaled 1,025 rushing yards, scored two touchdowns, and averaged 5.6 yards per carry. The best part was that Ward wasn’t the only running back who contributed at a high level to that Super Bowl-winning backfield in 2008; it also included Brandon Jacobs and Ahmad Bradshaw, earning the trio the nickname Earth, Wind, and Fire.

5. WR Earnest Gray - 1983 season

Giants fans may or may not remember wide receiver Earnest Gray, who played for the team from 1979 to 1984, but they will at least remember his 1983 season, when he recorded 78 receptions for 1,139 yards and 5 touchdowns on 165 targets. Gray then played only 12 games the following season with the G-Men before joining the St. Louis Rams in 1985, where he played only five games before retiring from the league.

6. WR Mario Manningham - 2010 season

When you think about the Giants’ key contributors in their 2011 Super Bowl run against the New England Patriots, wide receiver Mario Manningham stands out. His 2010 season was the best of his six-year professional career. Manningham totaled 944 yards and nine touchdowns on 60 catches, his career highs in receptions, receiving yards, and touchdowns in a single season.

Although he wouldn’t be the same after his 2010 season, his performance in Super Bowl 46 will never be forgotten, as he hauled in five catches for 73 yards.

7. LB Markus Golden - 2019 season

Markus Golden will be remembered primarily for his time with the Cardinals. He spent the first four years of his career in Arizona, was traded back to the Cardinals in 2020, and finished his career with the Steelers. His lone full season in New York in 2019 should not go unnoticed, though, as he totaled 72 combined tackles and 10 sacks, the most tackles in a single season of his career.

8. K Aldrick Rosas - 2018 season

It’s time we also start showing some love to these next three players, all former kickers who had one-season wonders with the Giants. First up is Aldrick Rosas, whose 2018 season stood out: he made 32 of 33 field-goal attempts, including a 57-yarder, and earned Pro Bowl honors. Rosas never attempted or made more field goals in a season again in his NFL career.

9. K Jay Feely - 2005 season

Jay Feely had a long NFL career, playing 14 seasons with six teams, including two seasons with the Giants (2005-2006). In 2005, he made 35 field goals on 42 attempts, with a long of 52 yards, and was perfect on all 43 of his extra-point attempts for 148 points. That was the most field goals and extra points Feely would have in a single season across his entire NFL career.

10. K Ali Haji-Sheikh - 1983 season

The last kicker we have to show love to is Ali Haji-Sheikh, who, in his rookie campaign in 1983, made 35 field goals on 42 attempts, a single-season record for the Giants at the time. That performance was so good that it earned him not just Pro Bowl honors, but first-team All-Pro honors as well. He played two more seasons with the Giants, a season with the Falcons, and ended his career with the Redskins in 1987, but his numbers never matched his rookie-year performance.

11. Safety Otto Schnellbacher - 1951 season

Let’s go back to former Giants safety Otto Schnellbach, who played for the G-Men from 1948 to 1951. For the first two years of his career, Schnellbach played for the Giants in the All-America Football Conference and was on the 1950 team when they joined the NFL. While he earned Pro Bowl honors that year, his 1951 season was even better, totaling 11 interceptions for 194 yards and earning him Pro Bowl and first-team All-Pro honors.

12. Safety Jimmy Patton - 1958 season

The next Giants safety was Jimmy Patton, who played his entire 12-year NFL career in New York. In 1958, he totaled 11 interceptions for 183 yards, earning Pro Bowl and first-team All-Pro honors.

That season also began a five-year streak of receiving both awards, though none of those seasons was statistically as good as 1958. It’s also worth mentioning that he was on the 1956 team that beat the Chicago Bears for the NFL Championship.

13. CB Willie Williams - 1968 season

Sticking with defensive backs, the next one-season wonder for the New York Giants was former cornerback Willie Williams, who spent eight seasons with the franchise. In 1968, he recorded 10 interceptions for 103 yards, a mark he never matched again in his career. Although he was a Pro Bowler the following season in 1969, his stats didn’t compare to the year prior.

14. WR Domenik Hixon - 2009 season

The next one-season wonder is wide receiver Domenik Hixon, a two-time Super Bowl Champion with the New York Giants, who helped them defeat the New England Patriots in 2008 and 2012. Hixon had a six-year NFL career, spending five seasons with Big Blue, but his best year came in 2009. He had 15 receptions for 187 yards and a touchdown, and as a returner, he added 57 kickoff returns for 1,291 yards, finishing with 1,731 all-purpose yards.

15. TE Larry Donnell - 2014 season

Former Giants tight end Larry Donnell spent all four seasons in the NFL with Big Blue, but his true breakout season came in 2014, when he had 63 receptions for 623 yards and six touchdowns. That performance puts into perspective how dominant he was in his second season with the Giants, as Donnell finished his NFL career with 969 yards and nine total touchdowns.

16. RB Orleans Darkwa - 2017 season

If anyone’s career took a few years to get going, it was former Giants running back Orleans Darkwa, who started with the Miami Dolphins, was released after four games, and signed with the Giants in 2014.

He didn’t break out until 2017, when he got an opportunity as Paul Perkins recovered from injury. He totaled 751 rushing yards and five rushing touchdowns, including a career-high 154-yard game with a 75-yard rushing touchdown, in an 18-10 victory over Washington. After that season, he was not re-signed by the G-Men and struggled to make an NFL roster despite workouts with several teams.

17. DE Azeez Ojulari - 2021 season

If there’s one recent player Giants fans wished hadn’t regressed, it’s former defensive end Azeez Ojulari. His rookie campaign in 2021 was as good as we could’ve hoped, giving us hope for what his career could become in New York. Ojulari totaled 49 combined tackles, 13 quarterback hits, eight tackles for a loss, and eight sacks.

While he would end up playing three more seasons with Big Blue, he never quite matched his rookie-year performance. Since then, he played for the Eagles last year, started this year on the Falcons' practice squad, and is currently on the Raiders' practice squad.

18. CB Terrell Thomas - 2010 season

The Giants had a rising star in cornerback Terrell Thomas heading into the 2010 season. In 2009, he recorded 85 combined tackles and five interceptions. In 2010, he built on that with 101 combined tackles, four forced fumbles, and five interceptions. Although he returned for one final NFL season in 2013, Thomas was never the same after tearing the same ACL twice in 2011 and 2012.

19. WR Dwayne Harris - 2015 season

Dwayne Harris may have played only two seasons with Big Blue, but he made his presence felt. Like David Wilson, Harris was a talented return specialist for the Giants, and his numbers are hard to ignore. In 2015, Harris caught 36 passes for 396 yards and four touchdowns, but he also stood out on special teams. He had two return touchdowns on 972 kickoff-return yards.

Although his 2016 stats weren't as good as the previous season, he still earned Pro Bowl honors.

20. TE Jake Ballard - 2011 season

Former Giants tight end Jake Ballard didn’t have a long NFL career; he played only three seasons professionally, two of them in New York, but his 2011 season shouldn't be forgotten. Ballard totaled 604 yards and four touchdowns on 38 receptions in 14 games played, helping the Giants win Super Bowl 46.

Those were Ballard’s only receiving stats as a Giant, and he added only seven more receptions, 75 yards, and two touchdowns in his career, which came in 2013 with the Arizona Cardinals.

Add us as a preferred source on Google