The New York Giants entered the 2024 season with cautious optimism, hoping to build upon the foundation laid by head coach Brian Daboll.
However, as they head into Week 11, the Giants find themselves at a dismal 2-8 record, ranking 31st in the league. Offensive struggles have been glaring, with the team positioned 26th in points scored and 27th in total yards. Defensively, they've fared slightly better but still sit at 23rd in points allowed. This underwhelming performance has intensified scrutiny on Daboll, especially considering his previous accolades as the 2022 AP Coach of the Year.
In contrast, the Dallas Cowboys, under head coach Mike McCarthy, began the season with high expectations, aiming to capitalize on their recent playoff appearances. Yet, they've stumbled to a 3-6 record, placing them 22nd in the league.
Offensively, the Cowboys are ranked 30th in points scored and 29th in total yards, a significant drop from their top-five offensive rankings in previous seasons. Defensively, they've also regressed, currently standing at 21st in points allowed. This decline has raised questions about McCarthy's leadership and adaptability.
Mike McCarthy should be ahead of Brian Daboll in hot seat odds
Despite the Giants' poor performance, the Cowboys' situation arguably warrants greater concern. McCarthy's tenure in Dallas has been marked by inconsistency. After a promising 12-5 record in 2023, the team's current struggles are alarming. The offense, once a powerhouse, has faltered, and the defense has failed to compensate.
Given the talent on the roster and the expectations set, McCarthy's inability to deliver results is glaring.
Head Coaches on the hot seat 🔥💺 pic.twitter.com/BGdf0rzOY1
— The 33rd Team (@The33rdTeamFB) November 17, 2024
In comparison, Daboll is in his third year with the Giants, a team still in the midst of a rebuild. While their 2-8 record is disappointing, the context differs. The Giants' roster lacks the depth and star power of the Cowboys, and Daboll's previous success in 2022 provides some leeway.
However, despite his struggles, the decision to potentially continue starting quarterback Daniel Jones has been met with skepticism. Reports suggest that Daboll and GM Joe Schoen believe Jones still offers the best chance to win, a stance that could impact their job security if results don't improve.
In conclusion, while both coaches are scrutinized, McCarthy's position appears more precarious. Despite a talented roster, the Cowboys' significant regression points to coaching deficiencies. Conversely, Daboll's Giants are underperforming, but the broader context of a rebuilding team offers a more nuanced perspective.
As the season progresses, both coaches must address their teams' shortcomings to secure their futures.