Skip to main content

Carson Schwesinger comparison makes Arvell Reese's DROY case even stronger

One-upping the masked Schwesinger.
ByMatt Sidney
New York Giants - rookie linebacker Arvell Reese
New York Giants - rookie linebacker Arvell Reese | Al Bello/GettyImages

The New York Giants haven't had a Defensive Rookie of the Year since Lawrence Taylor won the award in 1981. That's 45 years of waiting for another rookie to join LT in the Sack Tackle Phi fraternity. No pressure, Arvell Reese.

Nine games into his young career, the 21-year-old defensive demon is making an airtight case to stop the drought. He's already the betting favorite to win the award, and his playmaking has been a huge reason Big Blue's defense looks January-made under new DC Dennard Wilson.

I've already spent a good chunk of this season tracking Dominic Zvada's pursuit of Giants rookie history, so why not add another chase to the mix? This one involves Cleveland Browns linebacker Carson Schwesinger, last year's Defensive Rookie of the Year, and a nine-game comparison that should have Giants fans feeling holiday-pour toasty about Reese's chances at coming away with some hardware come awards night.

Arvell Reese is already outpacing Carson Schwesinger's DROY-winning rookie season

Schwesinger won DROY in 2025 after recording 156 tackles, beating out Seattle's Nick Emmanwori and Atlanta's James Pearce Jr. in the voting. The Brownie LB received 40 of 50 first-place votes, so it wasn't even close. Naturally, I wanted to compare and contrast.

Here's how Reese stacks up against Schwesinger through their first nine career games:

Arvell Reese vs. Carson Schwesinger stats through first nine games
Arvell Reese vs. Carson Schwesinger stats through first nine games | Matt Sidney (generated using AI)

Reese has already tripled Schwesinger's sack total through nine games while recording 23 more solo tackles. He's also proven himself as a dangerous pass rusher, should they go that route instead of keeping him as an off-ball backer, as highlighted by his ridiculous three-sack performance against the Philadelphia Eagles in Week 9.

The comparison gets even more interesting when you look at the history of the award.

Before Schwesinger won last year, an off-ball linebacker hadn't taken home DROY since Shaq Leonard in 2018. Now Reese has a chance to make it back-to-back winners at the position for the first time since Jerod Mayo and Brian Cushing did it back in 2008 and 2009. I was still in high school then -- yikes.

Of course, Schwesinger saved some of his best work for the second half of his rookie season, so Reese still has plenty of work cut out for him. And with Jets edge rusher David Bailey already sitting on 7.5 sacks, the competition isn't exactly going away. However, Pearce Jr. finished with 10.5 last year and still lost, so it's definitely not a pass-rush-or-bust award.

Last year's voting proved that rookie defenders don't need double-digit sacks to add to their mantle. Reese has already surpassed Schwesinger in nearly every major statistical category through nine games. If he keeps this up, it's going to be awfully hard to argue against him winning the same award.

Forty-five years is a long time for Big Blue Nation to wait for another Defensive Rookie of the Year. Reese absolutely has the, well, everything to finally end it.

Add us as a preferred source on Google