The New York Giants’ handling of Saquon Barkley’s departure has been scrutinized, dissected, and criticized from every angle. Some think it’s time to move on. Others—like former Giant Brandon Marshall—believe the Giants deserve every bit of the backlash they’re getting.
Marshall, who spent a brief stint with Big Blue in 2017, has remained close to the team and its fanbase. But when asked about Barkley’s success with the Eagles, he didn’t hold back. While some are ready to put the saga behind them, Marshall made it clear he isn’t. The Giants made their bed, and now they have to lie in it—literally.
Marshall told Fox News Digital:
"It’s what comes with it. This is the big leagues. The Tisch [and Mara] family has been phenomenal to me. … I do think that they can embrace a little change and get with the times a little bit in some areas. But I’m a big fan of the Giants. With that being said, no, this is absolutely what comes with it. You had a generational talent in your building, and you knew it. It’s why you drafted him."
Marshall: The Giants Brought This on Themselves
It’s not like the Giants weren’t warned. Even owner John Mara admitted on Hard Knocks he’d have trouble sleeping if Barkley ended up in Philadelphia. And yet, here we are—Barkley dominating for the Eagles while the Giants stumble to a 3-14 record.
Marshall isn’t interested in hearing about how it’s time to let it go. While some are calling the criticism excessive, he sees it as completely justified. The Giants knew exactly what Barkley was capable of, yet they let him walk—only to watch him thrive in an offense built to maximize his skill set.
And now, as Barkley prepares to play in the Super Bowl, the conversation isn’t going away anytime soon. The Giants may want to move forward, but as long as Barkley is tearing it up for a division rival, there will be no escape from the constant reminders of general manager Joe Schoen's mistake.
Whether fans agree with Marshall or not, one thing is clear: He’s not letting the Giants off the hook. And from the looks of it, neither is anyone else.