Skip to main content

Giants' Francis Mauigoa needs to rediscover what made him a top-10 pick

ByMatt Sidney
New York Giants offensive lineman Francis Mauigoa
New York Giants offensive lineman Francis Mauigoa | Icon Sportswire/GettyImages

The New York Giants didn't draft Francis "Sisi" Mauigoa with the 10th pick in the 2026 Draft to watch him get pushed around by defensive linemen. They took him because he was supposed to be the guy doing the pushing.

At Miami, Mauigoa was a 6-foot-6, 330-pound road paver at right tackle. He played with an edge and had the kind of nasty, must-delete-defenders-at-all-costs attitude offensive line coaches can only dream about. But through the first 10 games of his NFL career, that version of Mauigoa has been noticeably absent.

And while his transition to right guard hasn't exactly gone according to plan, I'm starting to wonder if the biggest thing holding him back is his confidence... or lack thereof.

Francis Mauigoa needs to get his swagger back before Giants fans start worrying

Pro Football Focus hasn't been particularly kind to the 21-year-old rookie. No acclimation period for you. Sisi currently has a 49.0 overall grade, ranking 65th among 77 qualified guards. His 51.0 pass-blocking grade ranks 56th, while his 47.4 run-blocking mark sits at an ugly 72nd.

For a top-10 pick acquired in the Dexter Lawrence blockbuster trade, those numbers aren't exactly what Giants fans had in mind.

But there's a pretty important detail here: Mauigoa spent his whole college career playing right tackle. Now he's learning guard against grown-man defensive tackles who are in his face almost immediately, without the extra space he was used to having on the outside. And it feels like he's thinking about that and living in his head a little too much.

CBS Sports' Josh Edwards recently pointed out that Sisi has struggled to sustain blocks because he isn't always bringing his hands along with his feet. His eyes have also gotten him into trouble identifying stunts, and he's occasionally lost ground against bull rushes.

Those are real concerns, but they also sound like the growing pains of someone still figuring out an entirely new position. Just because fans think it's easy to move from tackle to guard doesn't mean it actually is.

His rough outing against the Eagles was particularly ugly, with Jalen Carter and Philadelphia's defensive front giving him fits for days. But not a week later, against Washington, he responded by allowing just one QB hurry and no sacks or QB hits. Welcome to the ebbs and flows of being a rookie in the National Football League.

I have no doubt there's still an elite offensive lineman in there. We've seen glimpses of him.

What I'd love to see is Mauigoa stop looking so concerned about making the "right" decision that he forgets what made him such a monster at Miami. Trust your feet. Trust your hands. Trust that you're bigger and stronger than everyone else. But the main thing is trust your instincts.

Obviously, that's easier said than done when you're learning a new position. But the more comfortable he gets, the quicker he'll process what's happening, and the sooner he can get back to being himself. Sisi hasn't forgotten how to play football all of a sudden. He's learning on the fly and occasionally getting his lunch money taken by literal huge, enormous, strong people who have been doing this for years.

Give him time to find his footing (pun intended). I have a feeling the guy who used to bury defenders into the turf is still in there somewhere.

Add us as a preferred source on Google