Tommy DeVito had his moment with the New York Giants. Back in 2023, he led Big Blue to three straight wins as a starter, igniting a cult-like following in New York that would quickly die out. As fun as that stretch was, DeVito was never a premium backup.
The New England Patriots are about to learn that lesson the hard way. Drake Mayse suffered an ankle injury in Week 10 and is reportedly set to miss multiple weeks, if not the rest of the season. With nowhere else to turn after the NFL trade deadline, the Patriots are expected to make DeVito their starter for the upcoming stretch.
Unless he can rediscover the brief moment of magic he found in 2023, DeVito is about to tank New England's playoff hopes.
Patriots are about to endure a Tommy DeVito experience Giants fans want to forget
If we had some kind of memory-erasing machine, we'd preserve DeVito's first four starts with the Giants in 2023 and erase the final two. An undrafted rookie at the time, he stole our hearts with a few electric performances before crashing back to earth, eventually getting benched for Tyrod Taylor.
DeVito still deserves to be on an NFL roster, but he doesn't have the physical tools of a starting-caliber quarterback.
The Patriots already got a glimpse of his shortcomings in Week 10, as he had to replace Maye during a loss to the Detroit Lions.
DeVito completed just half of his passes, averaging 3.4 yards per attempt and throwing one touchdown and one interception. His -0.48 ranked 25th of 27 qualifying quarterbacks in Week 10, pending Monday Night Football. Only Daniel Jones and Carson Beck were worse.
Unless they sign a new QB, the Patriots are stuck hoping that DeVito can will them to a playoff appearance with Maye sidelined. Fans in New York know as well as anyone that he doesn't have that kind of run in him.
Patriots' Drake Maye injury exposes a roster mistake Giants were eager to avoid
It's easy to pick apart a lack of depth after an injury, but New England set itself up for failure by trusting DeVito as its backup quarterback. Maye takes plenty of hits, so the lack of a more reliable backup is an indictment of the Patriots' roster-building.
They'll pay the price, as DeVito is set to face the Buffalo Bills, the Minnesota Vikings, and the Kansas City Chiefs over the next month. It's hard to imagine New England emerging from that stretch with any remaining hope of a playoff appearance.
Joe Schoen and John Harbaugh made sure that they wouldn't have to deal with a lack of quarterback depth this season. Jameis Winston was seen as one of the league's best backups coming into the year, and when Jaxson Dart went down, New York was quick to respond by trading for J.J. McCarthy.
As a result, Harbaugh had the option to turn to McCarthy when Winston struggled. That proactive roster building has set the Giants up for a playoff push, while the Patriots seem destined to fall out of the race.
