For the many things that have improved under John Harbaugh, the New York Giants went from having one of the NFL's more efficient rushing attacks in 2025 to one of the league's least efficient in 2026. It's a weird paradox because outside of those few weeks with Najee Harris, it's basically the same RB room.
Cam Skattebo and Tyrone Tracy Jr. (who is currently on IR) are the 1-2 punch and Devin Singletary is the third back rotating in. So how does that justify such a major drop in efficiency? The run game is lifeless, and it's making things that much harder to move the ball and take pressure off J.J. McCarthy.
It's interesting because when the Giants hired Harbaugh, the mantra he wanted to bring to New York was to build an offense that'd be physical in the trenches and be able to run the ball with the best of them-- just like his offenses in Baltimore. But nothing has gone right for this group on the ground.
They're averaging just 3.9 yards per carry on the season, as the lack of a true feature back has hurt them. Harbs had Derrick Henry in Baltimore, so this is a major step down. They failed to acquire a marquee running back at the trade deadline, but these run game issues go far beyond the personnel.
So the age-old question on everybody's minds is: Who truly is to blame for these struggles? And the answer is that it falls on several different people, not just one.
Everybody deserves blame for the New York Giants' inability to run the ball
Since Matt Nagy's strong suit has never been scheming up the run game, Big Blue brought in a longtime colleague and supposed run game savant Greg Roman to help. Still, that hasn't done much, as they haven't been able to make life easier on the RB room since Jaxson Dart went down in Week 2.
That's one part of it, but the offensive line is culpable too. According to Pro Football Focus, the Giants' 49.6 run-blocking grade is third-worst (or 30th) in the NFL. Only the Titans and Packers are below them, and that's typically what happens when your only above-average OL starter is Andrew Thomas.
And given that Harbaugh did not get aggressive enough both in the offseason and at the deadline to bolster the room (despite his best efforts), he deserves some blame too. Wanting to pound the rock by running it back with an injury-prone RB room is organizational malpractice to the highest degree.
Frankly, for all of the stuff that is working against both Cam Skattebo or Tyrone Tracy Jr., neither of are feature-level running backs. They're both best operating as part of a committee as situational backs, while someone else takes on the majority of the touches. That's why Jonathan Taylor would've been such a perfect fit.
Right now, the New York Giants' run game is a complete mess, but it takes a village in this league--and this entire braintrust is culpable for the unreliable ground game.
