The New York Giants are 5-3-1 and sitting in first place in the NFC East, which is pretty unbelievable for a franchise that has won 13 games combined over the last three seasons. John Harbaugh has changed a lot in a short amount of time, and several of his offseason moves are already paying off.
Of course, the term "biggest offseason moves" is very subjective. Tremaine Edmunds probably would've cracked this list had he not suffered a season-ending chest injury, but with nine games in the books, these are the 10 moves I feel are most worth revisiting.
And just because a move lands near the bottom doesn't necessarily mean it was or is a disaster. Contracts matter, circumstances change, and some decisions need more time before we can properly judge them. With that said, here's how I'd rank the Giants' biggest offseason moves so far.
Giants' 10 biggest offseason decisions ranked at the midpoint
10. Handing the kicking job to Dominic Zvada
Recency bias is undefeated.
No one believes in Dominic Zvada more than I do (the 23-year-old can still make franchise history), but his recent struggles have really put my loyalty to the test. After opening the season a perfect 9-for-9, the undrafted rookie out of Michigan has missed six of his last 14 field-goal attempts, including a 33-yarder in last week's three-point loss to the Washington Commanders.
All six misses have come from the right hash, which Harbaugh believes is due to a mechanical issue. There's reason to believe Zvada-matic can figure it out, but given the Giants' recent run with shaky kickers, nobody's particularly excited about another season of worrying about leg day.
9. Signing WR Darnell Mooney
The Darnell Mooney signing made some sense at the time. He'd previously enjoyed his best season under Matt Nagy in Chicago, and the G-Men needed another receiver to give Jaxson Dart someone, anyone, else to throw to besides Malik Nabers.
Unfortunately, Mooney has struggled to make much of an impact, managing just 14 catches for 175 yards and no touchdowns, with rookie Malachi Fields overtaking him on the depth chart. Calvin Austin III's injury didn't help matters, either, forcing Mooney into a different role than originally intended. Still, it's a one-year, $3 million deal. Disappointing? Surely. Financially devastating? Hardly.
8. Trading away DT Dexter Lawrence
Trading Dexter Lawrence was always going to be controversial, and watching him rack up five sacks in nine games with the Cincinnati Bengals after failing to record a single one last season in New York hasn't exactly made the decision easier to stomach.
But Big Blue got the No. 10 overall pick in return, which they used to select Francis "Sisi" Mauigoa, while freeing themselves from an unhappy and uninspired financial obstacle. Sexy Dexy is still playing like one of the NFL's best defensive tackles, so I'm not ready to call this an outright win for New York just yet. But if Mauigoa develops into the offensive lineman the G-Men believe he can be, the trade could look a whole lot better in hindsight.
7. Signing CB Greg Newsome II
I've been saying this for a while now: the idea of Greg Newsome II has always been better than the actual player. This might be the first time I've been wrong.
The 26-year-old has allowed just 19 receptions in coverage through eight games, earning himself a three-year, $45.75 million extension during the bye week. The Giants needed someone to step up at cornerback, and Newsome has done exactly that. The new contract raises expectations, but it's hard to complain about what he's delivered so far.
6. Re-signing RT Jermaine Eluemunor
The Giants finally found some stability along their offensive line last year, and thankfully, they didn't overthink it. Re-signing Jermaine Eluemunor to a three-year, $39 million deal has helped keep the front from becoming the weekly disaster we've grown accustomed to around these parts.
He's allowed just one sack across 498 snaps, and his two-game absence with a calf injury showed how important he's become. Keeping Eluemunor also allowed New York to move Mauigoa inside to right guard, giving the rookie a chance to develop without immediately having to take over at tackle. Although his size, athleticism, and aggressiveness might be a better fit on the outside in the long run.
5. Signing DT DJ Reader
If you're still upset about the Lawrence trade, DJ Reader has at least made the fallout a lot less daunting.
The 6-foot-3, 330-pound defensive tackle signed a two-year, $12.5 million contract and currently has an 85.6 overall PFF grade, second among qualified DTs. He's been one of the team's most consistent and surprising players while costing a fraction of what Lawrence got in Cincy. Reader might be the biggest return on investment -- bang for your buck, if you will -- Big Blue made this past offseason.
4. Hiring DC Dennard Wilson
Dennard Wilson inherited a defense that finished 26th in scoring last season and 28th in yards allowed, and has turned it into, well, it being no longer a clown show. New York ranks fifth in total defense and third against passing yards, allowing just 305.7 total yards per game (184.1 passing yards per game).
The run defense still has its moments, and losing Brian Burns certainly didn't make Wilson's job of getting after the quarterback any easier. But he's fully embraced the blitz and gotten this group to play winning football, which feels like a luxury after what we Giants fans have had to suffer through in recent years.
3. Signing TE Isaiah Likely
Remember when people questioned whether Isaiah Likely could produce outside Mark Andrews' shadow in Baltimore? Well, 55 catches for 575 yards and seven touchdowns through nine games should help answer that.
The Giants gave Likely a three-year, $40 million deal, and he's already blown past all of his previous single-season career highs. He's become the offense's go-to guy regardless of who's playing under center, which has been especially important considering New York is on its third starter already. Likely could finish with the best receiving season from a tight end in Big Blue history if he keeps it up.
2. Drafting LB Arvell Reese at No. 5 overall
Arvell Reese has been everything the Giants could've hoped for when they took him fifth overall, and more. The former Ohio State demon has 81 tackles, including an NFL-leading 53 solo, and he's already the favorite to win Defensive Rookie of the Year.
His three-sack performance against Philadelphia was ridiculous, but what's been most impressive is how comfortable he looks wherever Wilson puts him. Reese is only 21 years old, and the G-Men might've already found the centerpiece of their defense for the next decade-plus. Reese gets the nod over signings like Likely because of his potential impact on the franchise moving forward, especially considering he's five years his junior. And it's not like Likely is ancient at 26.
1. Hiring HC John Harbaugh
Was there really any other choice?
The Giants made John Harbaugh one of the highest-paid coaches in football when they did their best Jerry Maguire impression, tossing him a five-year, $100 million deal, and nine games into watching Harby: Fully Loaded, I don't think anyone's asking for a refund.
Big Blue is 5-3-1 and sitting in first place in the NFC East despite losing Jaxson Dart and Brian Burns for the year. Harbaugh's even managed to win games with three different starting quarterbacks, which is borderline unfathomable, considering this team spent the last decade struggling to win games with one.
Harbs is firmly in the Coach of the Year conversation, and several moves on this list have his fingerprints all over them. There are plenty of others that didn't make the cut, but the biggest takeaway is that he's got New York in a position to do something it hasn't done since the 2011 season: host a playoff game at MetLife Stadium.
For a franchise that's had a top-10 pick three straight years, that's a pretty fascinating turnaround.
