If there’s one thing New York Giants fans have learned over the last few years (feels like hundreds), it’s that national respect is earned in inches, not miles. Despite an obvious shift in energy under new head coach John Harbaugh, the guys over at The Athletic aren’t ready to buy the hype just yet.
In his latest roster rankings of all 32 NFL teams, Austin Mock placed the G-Men at a really disappointing 26th overall, painting a picture of a team still as stuck as ever.
The ranking itself is a tough pill to swallow, especially with Mock highlighting the interior defensive line as the league's worst, with the secondary right there with it. While he gave flowers to the explosive potential of Malik Nabers and the intrigue of Abdul Carter, the overall viewpoint remains ice cold. It feels like a classic wait-and-see situation. But the harshest critique wasn't thrown at the defense -- it was aimed directly at the hopeful face of the franchise.
The narrative surrounding the quarterback position in North Jersey continues to be the ultimate divider between those who believe and those who don't. Mock’s assessment of the roster came with a slap in the face that should serve as the focal point for this team’s motivation in 2026:
"There are plenty of holes on this roster, however, and the future at quarterback is unclear after Jaxson Dart's unspectacular rookie season."
The Athletic's "unspectacular" evaluation of Jaxson Dart is a total nothingburger
To call Dart’s rookie campaign "unspectacular" isn't just a reach -- it feels more like a blatant attempt to ignore all context of the situation he walked into.
For the majority of last season, the 22-year-old was operating with a supporting cast that was arguably the most talent-depleted in the league. Operating without Nabers or Cam Skattebo for almost the entire season meant the former Ole Miss standout was essentially playing his rookie season with one hand tied behind his back.
Good luck to any quarterback coming into the league with a situation like that.
What people seem to forget is that Dart was widely viewed as a developmental project: a high-ceiling prospect who would need time to learn the playbook and get used to NFL speed -- you know... time to marinate.
Instead, he was thrust into the fire four games in and showed a level of poise and playmaking that should have silenced the doubters and naysayers. To take the roster he had and look as competent as he did was nothing short of incredible. Yeah, I said it.
Maybe Mock and the stat-heads just need to see the Harbaugh Effect in full swing with a healthy, upgraded roster before they change their tune. But for Dart, the message is loud and clear: the league is sleeping hard on this guy.
With Leek back in the fold and a much more stable environment around him, Dart finally has the situation he needs to turn that "unclear" future into a clear-as-day reality for the rest of the league.
Add us as a preferred source on Google