Skip to main content

Todd Monken is becoming a problem for John Harbaugh's Coach of the Year hopes

ByMatt Sidney
New York Giants - head coach John Harbaugh
New York Giants - head coach John Harbaugh | Todd Olszewski/GettyImages

I don't want to make this personal, but Todd Monken is dangerously close to doing me dirty twice in one calendar year.

Back in January, the former Baltimore Ravens offensive coordinator passed on joining John Harbaugh's New York Giants staff to become the Cleveland Browns' head coach. I took that decision particularly hard, considering I'd already made a pretty sweet "America Runs on Monken" graphic with unlimited other creative ideas that never got their chance to shine. And you thought I'd forgotten.

I had an entire vision planned for this man, and he threw it away for... Cleveland. Not that I'd ever exaggerate, but I've spent the better part of 10 months trying to move on. Now, Monken is threatening Harbs' chances of winning NFL Coach of the Year, and I'm starting to think this is personal.

Todd Monken is giving John Harbaugh some unexpected Coach of the Year competition

According to the latest betting odds, Harbaugh and Monken are practically tied in the Coach of the Year race. Kyle Shanahan (San Francisco 49ers) currently leads at around +280, while the former Baltimore colleagues are sitting somewhere between +360 and +370.

That's a pretty remarkable development considering Harbaugh entered the season among the favorites, while Monken was widely viewed as a long shot and something of a potential one-and-done guy.

Harbaugh has the G-Men sitting atop the NFC East at 5-3-1 despite losing Jaxson Dart to a season-ending injury in Week 2 and star pass rusher Brian Burns for the season the following week. That alone should give him plenty of stay in the conversation.

Unfortunately for Harbaugh's candidacy, Monken has the Brownies at 6-4, holding the seventh and final AFC playoff spot. Cleveland entered the year with a projected win total of just 5.5, which means the 60-year-old has already exceeded expectations with seven games left.

The first-time NFL head coach was supposed to be the offensive guru Giants fans desperately wanted alongside Harby. Instead, the Browns rank 27th in scoring at 18.8 points per game, with all six of their victories having required fourth-quarter game-winning drives. New York runs on Monken? More like, Cleveland runs on sunken... offense, am I right? I'll see myself out.

Meanwhile, Matt Nagy's group is averaging 22.6 points per game despite losing its starting quarterback almost immediately. Naturally, the offensive coordinator Giants fans thought they couldn't afford to lose is now winning games with the kind of gritty football Harbaugh built his reputation on. Hello, irony.

Of course, there's still plenty of season left, and neither coach is currently the favorite. But there's something particularly irritating about watching the guy Harbaugh openly admitted he was trying to recruit to New York potentially stand between him and his second Coach of the Year award (2019).

And wouldn't you know it, it just so happens the Browns visit MetLife Stadium in Week 15.

That December 20 matchup was already going to be a fun reunion of sorts. Now it could have some serious implications for the award race, especially if both teams are still fighting for playoff positioning.

I was willing to forgive Monken for robbing the world, and himself, of some truly generational creative stuff back in January. But if he comes into MetLife, beats Harbaugh, and eventually walks away with Coach of the Year, I might have to reconsider. There's only so much betrayal one man can take in a year.

Add us as a preferred source on Google