4 draft prospects Giants should target to replace Daniel Jones in 2025

As the New York Giants’ 2024 season slips further into free fall, the need for a new direction at quarterback has never been clearer.

With Daniel Jones likely losing his starting job to Drew Lock after the bye week, the team’s future at QB seems more uncertain than ever. Jones’s struggles have reached a tipping point, and the Giants now appear to be gearing up for a major transition under center. For fans, this signals a turning point. One that leads straight to the 2025 NFL Draft.

Finding the right quarterback isn’t just a priority; it’s essential if the Giants want to reclaim competitiveness in the NFC East.

The upcoming draft class offers a range of quarterback talent, from explosive playmakers to accurate pocket passers, each with the potential to bring stability and excitement back to New York’s offense. While Jones has had flashes of potential, his inconsistency has left the Giants in a familiar place: needing a QB who can make the tough throws, inspire confidence, and lead this team to victories.

Here are four realistic draft prospects the Giants should target in 2025 to replace Jones and finally find a franchise QB who can be the centerpiece of their future.

Four 2025 QB prospects NY Giants should target to replace Daniel Jones

4. Garrett Nussmeier, LSU

Garrett Nussmeier could be an exciting draft option for the Giants, bringing high-level arm talent, quick decision-making, and the ability to perform in clutch situations. Known for his fast release and playmaking ability, Nussmeier’s standout performances, like his ReliaQuest Bowl comeback win, showcase his potential to lead an NFL offense. His gunslinger style could inject energy into New York’s offense, something the team has been missing.

While his limited starting experience and lean build raise concerns, Nussmeier’s leadership and competitive edge make him worth the gamble. If he refines his decision-making and consistency in his first full season as LSU’s starter, he could provide the Giants with a promising young quarterback to develop.

3. Jalen Milroe, Alabama

Jalen Milroe could be an intriguing draft fit for the Giants, bringing explosive athleticism and a dual-threat skill set. In 2023, Milroe took over as Alabama’s starting quarterback, racking up 35 total touchdowns with 2,834 passing yards and 531 rushing yards. His standout performances, like his four rushing touchdowns against LSU and clutch game-winning throw in the Iron Bowl, showcase his playmaking ability and potential to deliver in high-pressure moments.

While Milroe’s raw talent is exciting, he still needs refinement, particularly with his mechanics, decision-making, and pocket presence. His big-play style and experience in a pro-style offense could add versatility and energy to the Giants, though he’ll need time and coaching to reach his ceiling.

2. Cam Ward, Miami

Cam Ward could be a compelling draft pick for the Giants, thanks to his elite playmaking skills and rapid development as a passer. From his FCS success at Incarnate Word to a dominant 2024 season at Miami, Ward has shown an ability to adapt, leading multiple programs to new heights. His quick release, strong intermediate passing game, and ability to create plays outside the pocket make him an ideal fit for a modern NFL offense. In high-pressure moments, Ward has delivered, helping Miami remain undefeated and even entering the Heisman conversation this season.

However, Ward still has areas for growth, particularly in handling pro-style offensive concepts and refining his mechanics. His arm strength, while good, isn’t quite elite, and his ball security in the pocket could use work. But with his blend of athleticism and dynamic skill, Ward offers a high ceiling that could make him a transformative QB option for the Giants if he continues his upward trajectory.

1. Shedeur Sanders, Colorado

Shedeur Sanders could be an ideal draft fit for the Giants, bringing elite accuracy, poise under pressure, and a high football IQ honed at both Jackson State and Colorado. With a standout 2024 season marked by a 72.9% completion rate and strong decision-making, Sanders has shown he can thrive in high-stakes moments. His ability to process defenses quickly, maintain precision on intermediate routes, and lead with poise in crucial situations makes him a plug-and-play option for any team needing a steady hand at quarterback.

Though he occasionally holds onto the ball too long, leading to preventable sacks, Sanders’ weaknesses are coachable. His natural leadership and proven consistency against top competition suggest he could adapt smoothly to the NFL. For the Giants, Sanders’ combination of accuracy, decision-making, and resilience could offer a promising foundation to build around for the future.

More NY Giants draft, news, and analysis