Drew Lock is just as confused about Giants' QB direction as everyone else

The New York Giants’ quarterback situation has officially become the NFL’s most bizarre subplot.

After a 2-8 start to the season, the Giants benched Daniel Jones, who hasn’t played up to his $40 million-per-year contract. Then they handed the starting job to Tommy DeVito, an undrafted second-year QB. Adding to the chaos, Drew Lock, the presumed next man up, has been relegated to backup duties behind DeVito.

Players and fans alike have questioned the Giants’ decision-making, but Lock’s recent comments shed light on just how strange things have gotten. Asked about not being named the starter after Jones’ demotion, Lock couldn’t hide his confusion.

The New York Giants are imploding

"That's a question that I might still have for myself. It was expressed to me that I was going to be QB2. Interesting situation..."

Lock’s response mirrors the sentiment of many within the organization and around the league. How did we get here?

The Giants’ quarterback drama is the culmination of poor planning and mixed signals from the front office and coaching staff. Let’s break it down:

• Daniel Jones’ Struggles: Jones hasn’t delivered this season, throwing just eight touchdowns against seven interceptions. Add a 2-8 record and a hefty $23 million injury guarantee looming for 2025, and it’s clear why the Giants wanted to protect themselves financially.
• Tommy DeVito’s Surprise Promotion: DeVito’s elevation to the starting role feels more like a strategic tanking maneuver than a genuine football decision. While DeVito has limited upside, his inexperience ensures the Giants remain in the mix for a top 2025 draft pick.
• Drew Lock’s Odd Limbo: Lock’s benching makes little sense from a competitive standpoint. The former Broncos starter has the experience and arm talent to give the Giants a better chance to win. But that’s precisely why he’s not starting—his presence under center could jeopardize the team’s draft positioning.

The optics are a mess. Financial decisions are trumping football, and the locker room is taking notice.

Drew Lock isn’t the only one speaking up. Defensive captain Dexter Lawrence recently defended Daniel Jones, calling him “the best quarterback on the team.” That’s not just a show of support for Jones, it’s a subtle dig at the coaching staff’s decision-making.

Reports suggest players are frustrated with the front office, viewing these moves as short-sighted and disrespectful. One offensive player bluntly told reporters, “We’re not idiots. They did it because of money.” That sentiment reflects a growing divide between the players and an organization that seems more focused on spreadsheets than winning.

Two years ago, general manager Joe Schoen and head coach Brian Daboll were riding high after a surprising playoff berth. Now, the honeymoon is over. Schoen’s personnel decisions have alienated players, while Daboll’s explanations for starting DeVito have been unconvincing at best and laughable at worst.

The Giants are a team with no direction, and their leadership is losing the trust of the locker room and the fanbase. If this season was about evaluating talent and building for the future, benching Jones was understandable. But the way it’s been handled, alienating players and sidelining Drew Lock for no clear reason, has turned this into a circus.

The Giants have 2025 firmly in their sights, hoping for a clean slate and a top draft pick to reset the franchise. But they’re taking the scenic route to get there, leaving frustration and confusion in their wake.

For Drew Lock, Daniel Jones, and even Tommy DeVito, the future is uncertain. And for Schoen and Daboll, it’s fair to wonder if they’ll be part of the Giants’ long-term plans.

One thing is clear: the New York Giants are a mess. Drew Lock said it best - this situation is “interesting,” to say the least.

More New York Giants news and analysis