Skip to main content

Giants called biggest playoff frauds despite sitting atop the NFC East

The Giants may have to prove all the doubters wrong between now and the rest of the season.
ByLogan VanDine
New York Giants - head coach John Harbaugh
New York Giants - head coach John Harbaugh | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

If you had told me that the New York Giants would be in first place in the NFC East in mid-November without their starting quarterback and best pass rusher, I would have thought you went cuckoo.

But that's where exactly where the Giants are ahead of what's expected to be a grueling final seven-game stretch. Despite losing Jaxson Dart in the second game of the year and Brian Burns the following week to season-ending injuries, New York still holds a two-game lead in the NFC East at 5-3-1.

Simply put, a lot of things have gone Big Blue's way. Between J.J. McCarthy reviving his career after the Minnesota Vikings dumped him, Arvell Reese putting together a superb rookie campaign, and Malik Nabers looking like, well... Malik Nabers, the G-Men are closer than ever to January football.

Despite not letting unfortunate injuries and missed opportunities derail their season, not everyone is buying Big Blue as legit contenders.

Giants called league's top frauds should only further energize the team

In an article for FanSided, Austen Bundy calls the Giants the biggest playoff frauds in the NFL, with Thursday night's collapse against the Washington Commanders one of the prime reasons.

"Thursday night's sub-two minute warning collapse to the Washington Commanders was the beginning of the end for New York," Bundy wrote. "That was one of the last remaining winnable games on the Giants' schedule as the second half of the season goes full tilt. Five of their next eight games are against teams either in a playoff spot or right on the bubble. That's five probable losses to tank the team right to the verge of elimination."

There's no sugarcoating it: last Thursday's loss to Washington was a backbreaker, especially since the Giants had a golden opportunity to expand their NFC East lead and perhaps put the division away for good.

While the Giants face a brutal stretch of the season, with the Jacksonville Jaguars (7-2) heading to the Meadowlands on Sunday, looking to cement that they're the best team in the AFC, we shouldn't write New York off that quickly.

When the G-Men hired John Harbaugh last offseason, they brought him in because his long resume as an NFL head coach showed he is a proven winner and will have his players compete in every game, no matter the situation. News flash, the Giants have done just that this season.

Despite everything they've gone through this season, they've been in practically every game. From their statement Week 1 win over the Dallas Cowboys to their goal-line stand back in Week 4 against the Arizona Cardinals, and even their overtime win against the Houston Texans, those have all been very impressive outings.

Also, how about the games this team nearly came back to win?

From nearly mounting a 14-point fourth-quarter comeback against the aforementioned Commanders, and their near 24-point fourth-quarter comeback the following week against the New Orleans Saints, there's no shame in saying that the Giants, last year or the year before, for that matter, would have given up in those contests.

They may not be the best team in the NFC, but they're in control of their division for a reason. You can blame the other teams in the NFC East for underperforming or being snakebitten by injuries, but Harbaugh has this football team playing hard week in and week out. The Giants still have plenty to prove over these final seven games, but calling them frauds already feels premature.

Add us as a preferred source on Google