Joe Schoen and the New York Giants shook the 2025 NFL Draft when they traded back into the first round with the Houston Texans to select Ole Miss quarterback Jaxson Dart with the 25th overall pick. It cost them quite a bit to essentially move up nine spots, but when the QB you want is there, make it happen.
To trade up, the G-Men sent their 34th and 99th picks this year, along with a third-rounder next year to get the deal done. It was a bold move. But one that was necessary and now gives New York a glimpse of what the future could look like.
Of course, the Dart selection was just the cherry on top of the Draft Night sundae. The biggest headline of the night was the Giants going literal best player available and drafting Penn State edge rusher with the third overall pick. It was an awesome night for Giants fans. And while Night 1 was electric, there is still so much more to come.
They’ve got five picks left—and just one on Day 2. That makes their upcoming third-rounder (No. 65) absolutely critical. There are still plenty of quality names on the board, but Schoen can’t afford to chase narratives or go for splash just to keep the party going. This pick needs to be smart, not sexy.
And that’s why, for all the upside and appeal, the Giants should stay away from wide receiver Tre Harris.
The Giants must refrain from drafting WR Tre Harris
Not to rain on the Giants’ draft parade, but pairing Jaxson Dart with his former teammate Tre Harris would be a mistake. Let’s be clear: Harris is a legit Day 2 prospect and absolutely deserves to hear his name called Friday. It just shouldn’t be the Giants making the call.
For those thinking how awesome it would be for the G-Men to have their own version of Joe Burrow and Ja'Marr Chase, they might want to reign it in a bit and not get swept away. There's no denying there's a connection between Dart and Harris. The two have combined for over 2,000 yards and 15 touchdowns together... but there are just more pressing needs.
In order to keep Dart upright and healthy, New York must address the offensive line. Whether it's a developmental offensive tackle like Boston College's Ozzy Trapilo or starting-caliber interior guy like Georgia's Tate Ratledge, they cannot overthink the pick. Schoen has done nothing to suggest he'd veer from his spectacular 2025 Draft strategy, but you never know. Burrow and Chase are awfully good together.
The O-line isn't the only position in need of some reinforcements. The interior defensive line, the running back room, and the cornerback room could stand to have some upgrades. And there are plenty of quality names still on the board.
Look, drafting Harris would be fun. The storyline writes itself, the chemistry is already there, and Giants fans would go nuts seeing Dart drop dimes to his college buddy. But fun can’t outweigh function—not on Day 2.
The Giants have too many needs elsewhere to justify the pick. If Harris somehow slides to Day 3? That’s a different conversation. At that point, the value would be undeniable, and Schoen should sprint the card in. Until then, though, the Giants need to stick to the plan. Protect Dart. Build the roster. Save the reunion tour for later.